Work

Towards a Grounded Theory of Administrative Cultures in a Post-Secondary Environment

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In an era of financial constraint universities are increasingly considering shared service centers as a model for administrative organization (Dove, 2004). Though much of the existing literature on this topic has approached the model from a value-neutral perspective, emphasizing efficiency, authors have nonetheless noted the significant cultural barriers to adoption of this new style of governance and organization (Richter & Brühl, 2017). Administrative staff in universities have become more professionalized in response to a more complex environment (Baltaru & Soysal, 2018; Gornitzka, & Larsen, 2004) but the cultural implications of this change remain underexplored in the literature (Whitchurch, 2006). Though organizational culture can be difficult to study (Schein, 1990), moments of transformational change can be opportunities to uncover implicit values and assumptions within an organization (Ravasi & Schultz, 2006). The implementation of a shared services model is a moment when issues of governance, authority, autonomy and mission are discussed. Many of the existing models of governance and organizational culture in higher education have a focus on academic structures and do not address the changing nature of administrative personnel and structures today (Birnbaum, 1988; Weick, 1976). I conducted a qualitative study of staff and perceptions of a shared services project with the intention of shedding light on current beliefs in higher education administration. I used Glaser and Strauss’s (1967) grounded theory approach, modified by Charmaz’s (2014) more recent work in this project. Data was collected via semi-structured interviews and was analyzed in part through the interpretation panel technique described by Noonan (2002). Participants were purposefully selected from a site where the phenomenon, a shared service implementation, was present. Through my previous master's work (Blizzard, 2020), I have identified two gaps in our understanding of organizational culture and decision-making in higher education. Whitchurch (2013) has contributed invaluable insight into the identity of administrators on campus but there remains additional work needed to describe the culture of these groups in similar detail to Bergquist and Pawlak’s (2007) description of academic cultures. There is also work ahead to operationalize appreciative inquiry principles into leadership practices as recommended by Bess and Dee (2014). This knowledge will support collegial decision-making approaches in an increasingly managerial operating model. Bess and Dee (2014) posited that much of the administrative and academic conflict in the academy is due to underlying differences in values. This project is an opportunity to surface these values and support dialogical approaches to conflict resolution.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7212411255
Cites: 80
Cited by:
Related to: 10