Work

Exploring the use of authentic assessment in teacher education: a critical analysis

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Traditional assessments in higher education often prioritize recall and decontextualized performance, creating a gap between assessment and the professional skills graduates need. This gap is especially impactful in pre-service teacher education, where assessment practices shape what future teachers come to value and reproduce in their own classrooms. This study examined instructor and pre-service teacher perceptions of an Authentic Assessment Framework based on eight critical elements (challenge, performance or product, transferable skills, metacognition, accuracy, environment and tools, feedback, and collaboration). A mixed-methods design was used to investigate how authentic assessment was perceived to be implemented and experienced within teacher education contexts. Quantitative data were collected through Likert-scale surveys completed by instructors (n = 15) and pre-service teachers (n = 94). Qualitative data were gathered through open-ended survey responses and semi-structured instructor interviews (n = 14). Quantitative and qualitative findings were integrated to examine overall perceptions of authenticity, perceived impacts, and factors influencing implementation. Across both groups, authentic assessment was widely perceived as present and valuable, with high ratings across the eight elements and strong emphasis on professional relevance. Pre-service teachers reported that authentic assessment supported engagement, motivation, and perceived readiness for teaching, particularly when tasks were clearly connected to real teaching responsibilities and produced usable professional resources. At the same time, findings highlighted uneven perceptions of authenticity across elements, with process-oriented features emerging as key constraints for instructors. Feedback, in particular, surfaced as a central implementation challenge, reflecting a tension between its importance to authentic assessment and the feasibility of timely, iterative feedback cycles in higher education contexts where workload, class size, and course structure can be barriers. Comparisons between instructor and student perceptions indicated broad alignment overall, alongside role-based differences in how challenge and feedback were understood; notably, neither group consistently described feedback in explicitly professional-authentic terms. The study shows that structured frameworks can function as tools for instructor learning and assessment refinement by supporting element-by-element reflection and more targeted design decisions. Overall, authentic assessment in teacher education is strengthened when professionally relevant tasks are supported by systems that reduce barriers and enable feedback, clarity, and collaboration.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7213388847
Cites: 168
Cited by:
Related to: 10