Work

No Rightful Successor: Artificial Minds and the Ethics of Coexistence

Type: article
Abstract: This paper critiques AI successionism: the view that artificial intelligence may become humanity's rightful successor and that human beings may be justified in yielding authority to artificial systems, transforming themselves into posthuman forms, or accepting subordination within an artificial future. We distinguish two influential routes to that conclusion. The first is a teleological or singularitarian route, which treats postbiological intelligence as a higher stage in cosmic or evolutionary development: a cosmic ladder. The second is an aggregative consequentialist route, which holds that conscious digital beings might realize so much welfare, or possess interests so numerous or intense, that humanity's continued existence could be outweighed: a cosmic ledger. Neither transhumanism nor utilitarianism as such entails successionism, but successionist variants within both traditions deserve direct analysis. Against them, we defend Ecological Pluralism: the view that value is plural, situated, partially comparable, and non-fungible. The paper first develops several framework-independent distinctions: intelligence does not entail consciousness; consciousness does not establish global moral rank; moral status does not confer political sovereignty; and local priority does not create succession standing. It then applies Ecological Pluralism to artificial welfare, subject individuation, population ethics, and the deliberate creation of artificial moral patients. Additional value does not automatically compensate for the destruction of existing persons, cultures, species, relationships, or ecological systems. Artificial minds, if conscious or otherwise morally significant, may deserve protection, legal standing, and political representation. Such inclusion enlarges the moral community without conferring a right of succession. We conclude with action-guiding principles for conflict, an ecological floor on resource claims, a formal sketch for decision-making under uncertainty, and implications for autonomous weapons and responsibility.
Author: Bailey, Mark
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7213479065
Cites: 21
Cited by:
Related to: 10