Work

Criminal Law and the Man Problem: A Man’s Ethical Inheritance via Drucilla Cornell

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This article offers an inaugural response to Ngaire Naffine’s 2019 work, Criminal Law and the Man Problem, in which she sets out a ‘call for justice’ whereby male criminal law academics must engage with criminal law’s patriarchal and violent history: “Men qua men, as the subjects and objects of criminal law, need to make themselves present and visible and then to examine their sex as a subset of the entire population, a little less than half, one with a set of historical and modern sectional interests.” The response offered here draws on, and celebrates, the work of the late Drucilla Cornell, as a way of honouring her life and scholarship. The ‘Cornellian methodology’ set out in the article is a three-part blueprint for an ethical inheritance of the criminal law, as per Naffine’s call. Firstly, Cornell’s adoption of Jacques Derrida’s concept of surenchère conveys how the inherited law of the past can be solicited via a ‘raising of the stakes,’ or an ‘upping of the ante,’ against the tensions within the received law. Secondly, Cornell’s distinctive legal methods of ‘recollective imagination,’ and the ‘imaginary domain,’ are utilised in order to reappropriate the Kantian ‘as if’ with regards to emancipatory feminist readings of the criminal law. Finally, Cornell’s delineation of the difference between a lived ‘position,’ and a lived ‘identity,’ is illustrated in order to ground the author as he who must respond to Naffine’s call for justice, from both his non-consensual position and his chosen identity.
Author: Chris Lloyd
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $2,190
OpenAlex ID: W7213488501
FWCI:
Cites: 35
Cited by:
Related to: 10