Type: article
Abstract: We demonstrate that the Law of Non-Contradiction (LNC) suffices to determine which theological system, if any, is true. We derive the existence of moral objectivity (MO) through the self-refutation of its denial, before demonstrating, from the LNC, the personal nature of its source and its constitutive structure. We then establish the necessity of ultimate justice (UJ) and the consequent existence of at least one personal sovereign judge enacting it beyond this present life. Lastly, we show the logical impossibility of multiple sovereign judges coexisting, leading to the conclusion of cosmic unity (CU): exactly one such entity can exist. The LNC and these derived premises (MO, UJ, and CU) serve as elimination criteria applied uniformly to every major system of belief—monotheistic, polytheistic, non-theistic, and atheistic. Every non-Islamic system is shown to violate at least one premise through formal contradiction or logical incoherence. Islam alone satisfies all four. First, Islam presents a scripture, the Quran, with no formal contradictions (eighteen alleged contradictions are examined and resolved). Second, it teaches that the human inclination to recognize objective moral truths is grounded in the divinely created innate disposition of fitra. Third, it ensures ultimate justice through precise individual judgment. Fourth, it affirms absolute divine unity through the doctrine of Tawhid. The argument is purely deductive, falsifiable, and produces a logically necessary conclusion: if the LNC is true, Islam is the only coherent theological system.
Author: Remadi, Adel
Language: English
Subfield: Religious studies
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7213491331
