Work

Drug (De)Criminalization and the (De)Stigmatization of People Who Use Illicit Drugs

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Researchers have theorized that drug criminalization and substance use stigma are structural drivers of the ongoing drug toxicity crisis. This dissertation conceptualizes the political function of criminalization as contributing to a system of stigma that exerts social control over people who use illicit drugs (PWUID). To address both structural drivers fueling the drug toxicity crisis, various stakeholders have suggested drug decriminalization as an anti-stigma intervention. However, little is known about how laypeople and PWUID, the targets of this intervention, conceptualize (de)criminalization and its potential relationship to substance use stigma. The three studies of this dissertation address this gap using a combination of document analysis and community-based participatory research. Study 1 used deputations sent to the City of Vancouver regarding a motion to decriminalize drugs within the city to explore how laypeople conceptualize drug (de)criminalization and its relationship to substance use stigma, and the potential implications of those conceptualizations for the autonomy of PWUID. Study 2 used the same dataset as Study 1 to examine how laypeople (re)define social category boundaries to include or exclude PWUID when discussing drug decriminalization, and what laypeople envision the implications of decriminalization will be for the (re)definitions of social category boundaries regarding PWUID. Finally, Study 3 used a community-based participatory research approach to explore how PWUID in the Niagara region conceptualize drug (de)criminalization and its relation to the (de)stigmatization of PWUID. Across the three studies, the findings suggested that although most participants supported drug decriminalization, stigmatizing beliefs about PWUID remained pervasive amongst both laypeople and PWUID themselves. PWUID were often framed as dangerous and engaging in an immoral activity (i.e., substance use), and this was found across participants regardless of their views on decriminalization. These stigmatizing beliefs ‘othered’ PWUID and were used to justify stripping PWUID of their autonomy. The perspectives of PWUID, however, largely consisted of pro-drug decriminalization views and a desire to preserve their autonomy through the passage of progressive drug policies. Overall, these findings emphasize the importance of including laypeople, especially PWUID, in policymaking processes to help design and implement progressive drug policies that more effectively address substance use stigma.
Institution: Brock University
Language: English
Subfield: Epidemiology
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7214138548
Cites: 126
Cited by:
Related to: 10