Work

Representation of LGBTQ+ communities in Ukrainian media discourse before and after Russia’s full-scale invasion : dissertation to obtain the degree of Doctor of Philosophy

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: PhD thesis to obtain the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Programme Subject Area 061 "Journalism" (06 — Journalism). — National University of Kyiv-Mohyla Academy, Kyiv, 2026. This PhD thesis analyses the transformation of LGBTQ+ communities’ representation in the Ukrainian media discourse before and after Russia’s full-scale invasion. The study reveals the discursive shift in human rights coverage accelerated by media platformisation and the wartime challenges. The main analytical framework comprises desecuritisation theory (Buzan et al., 1998; Hansen, 2000), i.e. the removal of LGBTQ+ rights from the domain of ‘existential threat’ to the realm of normalised public policy, and the concept of homopatriotism (Plakhotnik, 2019) as they influence the formation of queer civic agency. Russia’s full-scale invasion of February 24, 2022, jeopardises LGBTQ+ communities, rendering them a ‘double target’ in times of war. On the one hand, official Russian discourse systematically instrumentalises political homophobia as a tool of state-building and as a means of legitimising the war against Ukraine, depicting the West as morally degenerate in its acceptance of LGBTQ+ rights. On the other hand, the Ukrainian media exhibit internal tension: endorsing communities frequently assumes the character of ‘conditional inclusion’ and serves as an instrumental signal of alignment with European values, while the search for an internal enemy may be channeled toward marginalised groups. These challenges are accelerated by platformisation: surveys show that Telegram has established itself as the primary news source for approximately three-quarters of Ukrainian citizens. This demands a comparative analysis of two poles of the media system: institutional media outlets (‘TSN’ and ‘Suspilne’), which operate in accordance with professional standards, and noninstitutionalised digital platforms (the Telegram channels ‘Trukha⚡Ukraina’ and ‘Ukraina Seychas’), which function beyond systematic legal and ethical oversight. The object of this study is the representation of LGBTQ+ communities in Ukrainian media. The subject is the transformation of the content, visual, and receptive characteristics of the representation of LGBTQ+ communities in institutional media and noninstitutionalised digital platforms of Ukraine before and after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine (2019–2025). Three research questions are posed: (1) How has the representation of LGBTQ+ communities in Ukrainian media transformed before and after Russia’s fullscale invasion of Ukraine? (2) What dominant media narratives shape the image of LGBTQ+ communities in institutional media and non-institutionalised Telegram channels? (3) How do representatives of different segments of LGBTQ+ communities evaluate the strategies of their media representation in Ukraine? Drawing on a preliminary review of the literature and an analysis of the socio-political context, the study formulates an initial research assumption that, under conditions of war, the Ukrainian media system enacts two competing discursive logics: institutional media carry out a partial desecuritisation of LGBTQ+ identities through the integration of these communities into the national defense narrative, with the ‘Hero-Defender’ being the dominant archetype, whereas non-institutionalised Telegram channels enact the inverse process, resecuritisation, through strategies of affective mobilisation. The study also aims to identify a structural asymmetry in the visibility afforded to different community segments. The theory and methods are based on the integrative model of the collective refiguration of discourse, combining the paradigm of social constructionism (Berger & Luckmann, 1966; Jørgensen & Phillips, 2002), theories of representation and the social production of meaning (Hall, 1997; Tuchman, 1972, 1978), and critical discourse analysis (Fairclough, 1995). Drawing on Paul Ricoeur’s concept of ‘threefold mimesis’ (Ricoeur, 1984), the study traces the configuration of reality in media, wherein social actors are assigned varying extents of agency and narrative archetypes (ranging from the ‘Hero- Defender’ to the ‘Victim’ or a passive object). Considering S. Fish’s theory of ‘interpretive communities’ (Fish, 1980), the stage of refiguration is studied: how members of LGBTQ+ communities collectively decode media constructs within the safe communicative ‘backstage’ (Goffman, 1959), thereby forging their own narrative identity. The mechanisms of affective othering on unregulated digital platforms are conceptualised through the theory of ‘affective economies’ (Ahmed, 2014) and the parasocial contact hypothesis (Schiappa et al., 2005). The methods of the study are grounded in the very nature of its object: latent semantic structures, ideological myths, and narrative archetypes cannot be reduced to formalised quantitative measures and require in-depth interpretive analysis. Consequently, a multimethod triangulation design (Denzin, 1978; Bekhet & Zauszniewski, 2012) comprising three levels is employed. The structural level is constituted by quantitative content analysis (N = 1,223 items for the period 2019–2025; intra-coder reliability κ > 0.80), enabling the mapping of visibility hierarchies and the media agenda. The ideological narrative level integrates critical discourse analysis following Fairclough (1995), qualitative narrative reconstruction, and multimodal analysis of visual materials (Kress & van Leeuwen, 2006). The receptive level is grounded in three homogeneous online focus groups composed of individuals with diverse identities, i.e. gay and bisexual men; lesbian and bisexual women; and transgender and queer individuals, which enabled the incorporation of the intersectional character of lived experience under the security constraints imposed by martial law. The originality of the findings lies in the comprehensive resolution of the research problem concerning transformation processes in the media representation of LGBTQ+ communities under conditions of full-scale war. For the first time in Ukrainian media studies, the coverage of this subject has been comprehensively analyzed over time in dynamic perspective, providing empirical substantiation of a discursive shift: the transition from the representation of victimisation to the predominance of a desecuritisation narrative. A significant contribution lies in the introduction of findings from a systematic study of noninstitutionalised digital platforms, which reports a structural gap between journalistic standards and the algorithmic logic of affective engagement. A systematic conceptualisation of the phenomenon of ‘parasocial counter contact’ is proposed as a specific form of mediamediated interaction on unregulated digital platforms, theoretically extending the mechanism of negative parasocial contact documented in the literature (Schemer & Meltzer, 2020) by three structural characteristics: a strategy of negative hypervisualisation of deviance, the instrumentalisation of platform affordances, and the absence of ethical gatekeeping. The phenomenon of ‘nominal neutrality’ is conceptualised as a specific dysfunction of the journalistic standard of objectivity (Tuchman, 1972), theoretically complementing the concept of ‘false balance’ (Boykoff & Boykoff, 2004) with the dimension of selective application of professional standards within a single media outlet. The findings confirmed the initial research assumption regarding a profound structural divide within the Ukrainian media. The overwhelming majority of media representation on this subject (84.4 %) was established to be generated by institutional media outlets, while non-institutionalised Telegram channels account for a smaller share (15.6 %), showing the operation of a mechanism of ‘symbolic annihilation’ (Tuchman, 1978) through the neglect of LGBTQ+ individuals’ everyday experiences. The phenomenon of ‘seasonal representation’ was identified: community visibility is entirely contingent upon calendarbased activism (with the peak in June), and following the onset of the full-scale invasion, this disparity was exacerbated—media required more than 18 months to restore prior levels of attention. A critical level of media androcentrism was recorded: mentions of gay men appear 5.9 times more frequently than those of lesbian women, producing, in the context of war, a "double invisibility" of women’s experience of resistance. The ‘transgender visibility paradox’ was also identified: a high frequency of mentions does not correlate with destigmatisation but instead reduces the group’s subjectivity to a corporeal-sensationalist dimension. Analysis of the displacement of the media agenda following the full-scale invasion revealed a radical transformation of the content of representation. Using Suspilne as a case study, the share of coverage regarding the war’s impact and LGBTQ+ participation in state defense increased from 1.27 % to 11.59 %, marking a shift from victimization to the dominance of the ‘Hero-Defender’ archetype. This process is conceptualised as mediatised desecuritisation, in which the right to equality is reframed as an act of legal justice toward the warrior. Qualitative analysis revealed distortions in the ethical standards of this process: ‘nominal neutrality’ was identified, whereby the mechanical transmission of discriminatory acts without value-based contextualisation leads to the legitimation of antidemocratic practices. The commercial outlet ‘TSN’, by contrast, pursues a strategy of the ‘economy of drama’, commodifying LGBTQ+ identities for the construction of sensationalist ‘formula stories’. Within the Telegram segment, the dominance of affective othering and network gatekeeping was established. The analysis provides grounds for asserting that these platforms’ transition to the Ukrainian language constitutes a form of ‘discursive mimicry’: formally appropriate terminology coexists with the ‘neutral pl
Language: Ukrainian
Subfield: Communication
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7214139465
Cites: 236
Cited by:
Related to: 10