Risk Assessment Methodologies for Imports of Products of Animal Origin: A Systematic Review of Formal and Informal Trade Pathways
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Study design: Systematic Review
Abstract: The international trade of products of animal origin (POAO) represents an important pathway for the introduction of transboundary animal diseases (TADs). Import risk assessments (IRAs) are widely used to evaluate this risk; however, approaches vary considerably depending on the type of commodity, trade pathway, and data availability. This study systematically reviewed published IRAs to examine the frameworks, methodologies, data sources, and disease–commodity combinations used to assess risks associated with both formal (legal) and informal (illegal) trade of POAO. Out of 2,541 records, a total of 50 records met the inclusion criteria for this systematic review, describing a total of 51 different import risk assessment studies. The most widely adopted and internationally recognised frameworks were included, representing a range of analytical methodology, including qualitative, semi-quantitative, and fully quantitative approaches. Across all eligible studies, there was a strong focus on the early stages of the risk pathway, particularly entry assessment (45%), while the remaining studies (55%) evaluated the entry phase combined with exposure, consequences, or subsequent spread. The most studied viruses were african swine fever virus (ASFV) (n = 19, 37%), foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) (n = 17, 33%), and classical swine fever virus (CSFV) (n = 8, 16%), highlighting their global impact on livestock production and trade. Meat and meat products were the most frequently evaluated commodities (n = 39, 76%), particularly those derived from pigs and cattle, and were often linked to high-risk pathways, such as passenger-mediated transport of contaminated products and informal cross-border trade. In contrast, milk and dairy products were less frequently assessed (n = 9, 18%), while commodities such as bushmeat and fish products were only rarely considered. Formal trade pathways dominated the literature due to the availability of structured data, while informal trade was less frequently assessed despite being recognised as an important route for disease introduction. Informal pathways mainly involved passenger transport of products in personal luggage, while other pathways, such as postal consignments or courier shipments, received little attention. These findings highlight gaps in current IRA studies, particularly regarding informal trade. Addressing these gaps will require stronger surveillance and monitoring systems, improved reporting of informal product movements, and greater international collaboration to support more realistic and comprehensive risk assessments.
Source: Research Square
Language: English
Subfield: Animal Science and Zoology
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7214160184
