Strong Centers, No Domination: Shared Infrastructure, Collective Power, and the Problem of the Irreplaceable Center
Type: article
Abstract: Powerful organizations possess an advantage that is easy to overlook: they have machinery for combining resources. They can locate expertise, assign responsibility, coordinate specialized work, preserve institutional memory, mobilize money, and turn decisions into action. Large populations may collectively possess extensive knowledge, skill, experience, and social legitimacy while remaining far less capable of acting together because these capacities are dispersed and costly to organize. This paper argues that shared sociotechnical infrastructure can reduce that gap. Common systems can make knowledge reusable, expertise easier to find, disagreement easier to inspect, decisions easier to execute, and previous collective effort easier to build upon. Infrastructure can therefore produce counterpower not by transferring a fixed quantity of authority from one ruler to another, but by increasing what dispersed actors can do together. The solution, however, creates its own problem. Infrastructure that becomes highly useful also becomes highly central. If people cannot realistically continue without its operator, infrastructure designed to reduce dependence has created a new dependence of its own. The central institutional problem is therefore not how to eliminate centrality, hierarchy, expertise, or economic reward. It is how to prevent useful forms of power from becoming automatically convertible into unrelated and eventually irreplaceable forms of control. The paper argues for strong but replaceable centers: common standards without a permanent sovereign, expertise without general authority, operational control without ownership of others' ability to continue, and commercial activity without ownership of the commons. Exit alone is insufficient. The stronger test is whether people can preserve their capabilities, establish viable alternatives, and, where necessary, rebuild the functions on which they depended. The kOA ecosystem is examined as a reflective design case through which these problems became concrete. It is not presented as empirical validation. The broader claim is that collective autonomy requires powerful infrastructure, but infrastructure compatible with non- domination must remain open to challenge, substitution, and succession.
Author: McCormick, Réjean
Language: English
Subfield: Management Information Systems
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7214508995
