Work

The Ethics of Circumcision

Year: 2023
Type: article
Abstract: In many cultures, children with intersex traits are subjected to medically unnecessary genital operations in an attempt to reshape their sexual anatomy to approximate a more stereotypical male or female appearance.In addition to these surgeries, there are three main patterns of medically unnecessary genital operations performed on non-intersex children across the globe.In the first pattern, the dominant culture endorses routine or religious genital cutting only of boys, as in the United States, Israel, Afghanistan, or Saudi Arabia, for instance.In these cultures, girls are ineligible for genital cutting, or may be seen as deserving protection from it.In the second pattern, neither boys nor girls of the dominant culture have their genitals cut unless there is a strict medical indicationwhich in these contexts is rare.This is the prevailing pattern throughout Europe and indeed most other parts of the world.In the third pattern, both boys and girls of the dominant culture have their genitals cut for non-medical reasons, for example, in the context of a rite of passage or religious initiation.Typically, this occurs around puberty, but the timing ranges from right after birth to before marriage.In this chapter, I present a moral argument in favor of the second, "European" pattern, both as a matter of ethics and gender equality.I do not discuss legal implications.In other words, I argue that, morally speaking, neither boys nor girls who are too young to consent should have their genitals cut-to any extent-unless it is medically necessary to do so, whether or not they have intersex traits.The alternative, from a gender equality perspective, would be to argue that both boys and girls should have their genitals cut on an equal basis, for example, by a doctor using sterile instruments.But from an ethical perspective, I argue, this would not be acceptable.
Author: Earp, Brian
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7214513161
FWCI:
Cites: 135
Cited by:
Related to: 10