Revisiting apologies: an examination of the prevalence, predictors, composition, and perceptions of suspect apologies in police interviews
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Apologies occur in criminal justice settings. However, little is known about their prevalence and composition, as well as how they are perceived by others. In this dissertation, I examined suspects’ apologies in police interviews and how they were evaluated by observers. In Study 1, I investigated how often suspect apologies occurred in a sample of real police interviews and explored potential predictors of their occurrence (i.e., suspect demographics, interview tactics, suspect demeanors, and interview conditions). Suspects apologized at a substantial rate (i.e., 37%), and just under one-third of these apologies had been prompted by the interviewer. While the number of interviewers showed some predictive effect, none of the other tested variables were significant. In Study 2, I examined the composition of suspect apologies. Specifically, I coded the same police interviews as in Study 1 for the presence of six apology components and eight pseudo-apology components using established typologies. Clear differences emerged with regards to component frequency. Acknowledging responsibility, providing an explanation, and expressing regret were the most common apology components. Vague offence acknowledgements were less frequent but still more common than other pseudo-apology components. In Study 3, I examined the effect of apology composition on observers’ perceptions of suspects. Apologies containing an acknowledgment of responsibility tended to increase guilt verdicts, support for criminal charges and harsher punishment. However, these effects were not necessarily linear, with punishment severity peaking when suspects acknowledged responsibility, expressed remorse and provided an explanation. Overall, these studies help address a gap in the literature while also informing criminal justice professionals about the potential impact of apologies.
Author: Villeneuve, Katrina
Institution: Ontario Tech University
Language: English
Subfield: Social Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7214862151
