Work

The Evolutionary Inheritance Framework Ecology, Cognitive Mode and Symbolic Inheritance in Reconstructions of Deep Human History

Type: book
Abstract: Reconstructions of the deep human past that draw on myth, monuments and comparative religion are prone to a familiar failure. A vivid narrative is treated as evidence, and later work then cites the narrative in support of itself. The popular lost-civilisation literature is the best-known example. The opposite re-sponse, dismissing all such material, discards cases in which oral tradition has been shown to preserve real environmental memory. This paper presents Evolutionary Inheritance, a framework that links ecolog-ical change, cognitive mode and symbolic inheritance in the history of human societies while keeping the strength of each claim visible. The framework rests on a three-tier discipline. Established claims rest on published, replicated evidence. Structural hypotheses are the author’s own readings of established facts, argued against named alterna-tives. Interpretive narratives are specific reconstructions offered as narrative and not as record. A claim may not be cited at a higher tier than its evidence supports, and claims that fit no tier are declined and listed with reasons. Within that discipline we advance a small set of structural hypotheses. Exposed Ice-Age continental shelves supported coast-following foraging populations whose record is now largely submerged. Those populations experienced displacement pressure as the shelves were flooded. Hierarchy among foragers depends on storable surplus and not on scarcity, so a comparatively egalitarian coastal world is conditional on minimal storage. Chronic environmental unpredictability shifts processing toward a fast, reactive mode, a distinction in kind that exists in every human nervous system. Two anchors from the established literature complete the picture: symbolic systems are continuous with biological evolu-tion, and transmitted memory is compressed in ways that vary with how it is transmitted. Ancient sys-tematic knowledge is treated as real intellectual achievement in each tradition’s own vocabulary. We state six testable implications with conditions under which each would fail, tabulate the specific claims the framework declines, and give a scoring rubric for assigning claims to tiers. The paper makes no claim that a lost advanced civilisation existed, takes no position on the truth of any religious tradition, and does not treat physics, cognition and history as one mechanism. Its aim is a smaller argument that can be checked.
Author: Indur, Kiran
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7215010966
Cites: 59
Cited by:
Related to: 10