Religious Authority and the Discursive Legitimation of Polygamy: A Political Socio-Legal Study in Riau, Indonesia
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Religious discourse shapes how Muslim communities understand contested areas of family law, including polygamy. Although previous studies have examined polygamy in relation to theology, state regulation, gender, and legal pluralism, less is known about how religious actors make particular interpretations of polygamy socially credible through everyday educational and communicative practices. This study examines how religious actors construct and reproduce the legitimacy of polygamy in Pekanbaru and Kampar, Riau, with fieldwork concentrated in Kampar Regency. Drawing on Pierre Bourdieu’s theory of practice and Michael W. Apple’s perspective on ideological reproduction, the study uses a qualitative political socio-legal approach based on semi-structured interviews, participant observation, and documentary analysis. Fieldwork was conducted through four observation phases involving 160 religious figures in Kampar Regency, supported by interview and documentary evidence. The analysis distinguishes between two related processes: Apple’s framework is used to examine how particular meanings are selected and reproduced in educational and communicative settings, while Bourdieu’s framework is used to examine field relations, cultural, social and symbolic capital, and the production of religious authority. The findings indicate that polygamy was frequently framed in religious settings as Sunnah and as part of religious obligation, whereas references to Indonesian legal procedures appeared less prominently. Religious actors’ cultural knowledge, social networks, and symbolic recognition strengthened their ability to circulate particular interpretations and present them as credible within the religious field. The study contributes to political socio-legal scholarship by showing how the legitimacy of polygamy is produced not only through religious texts or formal law, but also through the everyday interaction of discourse, educational practices, institutional authority, and symbolic power.
Source: JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah)
Authors: Subaidi, Zaizul Ab. Rahman
Language: English
Topic: Asian Studies and History
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7215103528
