Work

Moderno ali tradicionalno? Do katere mere je pisanje s pisalom na papir drugačno od tipkanja na računalnik in kako vpliva na priklic?

Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: This study investigated the effects of note-taking methods — longhand versus computer typing— on recall among high school students. Building on Mueller and Oppenheimer’s findings and thepsychological theory of Levels of Processing, the study hypothesized that handwritten notes wouldlead to better recall due to more engaged cognitive processing. Twenty international school studentsaged 16–17 were divided into two groups: one using paper and the other using computers to takenotes on 17 presented facts. After a 10-minute delay involving an interference task, participantswrote down as many facts as they could recall. Results showed that the paper group significantlyoutperformed the computer group, with a mean recall of 7.4 versus 4.4 facts respectively. A Mann-Whitney U test confirmed statistical significance (U = 23, p < 0.05), allowing the rejection of thenull hypothesis. The findings support the theory that handwriting fosters deeper processing throughsummarization and paraphrasing, while typing encourages verbatim transcription and shallower encoding.Strengths of the study include ecological validity, control of extraneous variables, and standardizedprocedures. However, limitations such as a small sample size, potential researcher bias,and variability in individual cognitive styles affect generalizability. Future studies should considerlarger samples, extended exposure times, and analysis of the note content. Despite limitations, resultssuggest that traditional handwritten note-taking may enhance learning and memory retentionmore effectively than computer-based methods, challenging the growing reliance on digital toolsin education.
Source: VICEVERSA
Language: Slovenian
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7215405756
FWCI:
Cites: 3
Cited by:
Related to: 8