Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Scalar-tensor theories of gravity have emerged as compelling alternatives to General Relativity, offering potential explanations for cosmic acceleration and the nature of dark matter. These theories introduce additional scalar fields that couple to matter, leading to modifications of gravitational interactions through fifth forces. However, such modifications must be carefully constructed to evade stringent local tests of gravity, necessitating the development of screening mechanisms that suppress scalar effects in well-tested high-density environments like the Solar System, while preserving phenomena in low-density galactic outskirts. Understanding these screening mechanisms and scalar fifth forces on galactic scales forms the central focus of this thesis. In chapter 1, we detail the historical background of modern cosmology and galactic physics, as well as the theoretical framework of scalar-tensor theories, with particular focus on chameleon and symmetron models. The numerical and statistical methodologies required to implement these theories in realistic galactic environments are outlined in chapter 2, including a mock-galaxy generation pipeline that transforms observable galactic properties into detailed density profiles, and the numerical solver we utilise to compute accurate scalar field configurations. The core investigations of this thesis examine the validity of approximations and assumptions commonly adopted in scalar field studies. Chapter 3 rigorously tests frequently used methods for estimating screening radii --- the boundaries of screened regions within galaxies. Through precise numerical solutions, and novel methods to calculate the screening radii, we reveal significant discrepancies between approximate and true screening radii. We find that the widely used binary screening condition, based on the galaxies virial potential, drastically underestimates the parameter space where galactic discs are screened, leading to erroneously tight constraints. While more sophisticated partial screening approximations perform better, they still exhibit systematic errors when Compton wavelengths become comparable to galactic scales, suggesting that many existing observational constraints may be overstated. Building on these methods, chapter 4 examines the validity of assuming continuous stellar density profiles in f(R) theories. When Compton wavelengths approach typical stellar separation --- as we find to be the case in screened galactic regions --- the discrete nature of stars significantly alters scalar field behaviour. We posit that the field profile becomes highly heterogeneous in this regime: relaxing to values determined solely by smooth dark matter in the interstellar medium while becoming strongly screened near individual stars. This shifts screening radii toward galactic centres, potentially exposing previously screened regions to scalar modifications. Chapter 5 develops a novel framework to measure scalar theories through weak gravitational lensing observations, with an application focused on the radial acceleration relation in galaxies. We test our framework for several symmetron-based models that introduce small photon masses, enabling photons to couple to scalar fields and exhibit fifth-force-like lensing enhancements. This work opens new observational pathways for constraining modified gravity theories. The key findings and broader implications of this research are presented in chapter 6.
Author: March, Bradley
Institution: University of Nottingham
Language: English
Subfield: Astronomy and Astrophysics
Field: Physics and Astronomy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: scalar-tensor gravity, fifth force, screening mechanisms, chameleon mechanism, f(R) gravity, Compton wavelength, Galactic disc, weak gravitational lensing, radial acceleration relation, photon mass, modified gravity constraints, dark matter, stellar density profiles, galactic outskirts, solar system tests of gravity
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7216772043
