Work

Philosophy by Equivocation: A Methodological Reset for Comparative Philosophy

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Debates on comparative philosophy continue to subscribe to broad culturalist assumptions regarding the nature of the philosophical traditions that one chooses to compare. These assumptions relate specifically to the idea that a text, figure, or a broadly construed tradition, is a relatively stable comparandum with an enclosed conceptual scheme that is internally coherent. This essay proposes an alternative starting point, arguing that persistent debates on the promise or perils of comparative philosophy remain bound to an inherited and underexamined genealogy of the concept of culture. By tracing this genealogy through the tradition of philosophical anthropology, the essay demonstrates how the language of Bildung encodes a civilizational teleology that has constrained comparative thinking across generations—including in ostensibly pluralistic and ecumenical versions of the tradition. Rather than abandoning the concept of culture, as has been proposed in some recent critical accounts of comparative philosophy, the essay instead identifies an interdisciplinary path to recouping the concept for the purposes of comparison. Central to this reconfiguration is the claim that cultures, freed from an assumption of conceptual stability and systematicity, are constantly mobile sites of contestation and collaboration. Philosophical texts emerge in this landscape not as fixed repositories of meaning but as cultural performances embedded in specific configurations of time and space. The essay concludes with a proposal of an alternative methodological model—a philosophy by equivocation—which it claims is well-suited to the possibilities that the revised understanding of culture offers the comparative philosopher.
Author: Sikri, Rohan
Institution: New York University
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7216962779
FWCI:
Cites: 7
Cited by:
Related to: 10