A Brief Cognitive Behavioural Intervention to Reduce the Negative Effects of Social Networking Site Use
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: Online social networking site use has become a daily practice for many. A range of negative psychological outcomes have been linked to social networking site use, particularly with platforms of a highly visual nature, including reduced well-being and body image. Social comparison processes (e.g. appearance-based comparisons) play a considerable role in the association between highly visual social networking site (HVSNS) use and well-being outcomes; HVSNSs provide opportunity for unrealistic social comparisons due to the curated and positive nature of images presented. A need for psychology-informed interventions designed to reduce the negative impact of HVSNS use exists. Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) techniques have demonstrated success in therapeutic programs delivered both in person and via an online format, and in addressing social comparison processes generally, rendering CBT a promising treatment modality for addressing these processes. The overall aim of this research project was to develop and assess the effectiveness of a brief CBT-based program, Social Media Aware (SMA), designed to minimise the negative impact of HVSNS use on a range of well-being outcomes. A systematic scoping review with meta-analysis was conducted to map the existing literature focussed on interventions for psychological impacts of HVSNS use, to inform program design. While highlighting the infancy of the field, findings demonstrated the potential utility of CBT-based and other psychology-informed interventions in minimising the negative impact of HVSNS use on a range of well-being outcomes. A CBT-based micro-intervention, ‘Social Media Aware’ (SMA), was then developed. This short interactive video intervention focused on cognitive restructuring techniques and targeted a range of negative thoughts stemming from social comparisons across many areas of life and the self. This included perceived success, happiness, relationships, and attractiveness. A pilot study (n=59) was conducted to assess the acceptability of the program and the feasibility of a subsequent randomised controlled trial. Pilot study results demonstrated acceptability of the program, in addition to immediate reductions in negative affect. Data were also collected regarding the types of negative thoughts experienced by participants when using HVSNSs, which confirmed the wide range of thoughts targeted by the SMA program. A randomised controlled trial (n=167) was conducted, and modest but statistically significant improvements were shown across all areas assessed in the desired directions among those who received the intervention, compared to the control group. This included state body satisfaction, negative affect, positive affect, satisfaction with life, and negative automatic thoughts (frequency and believability). No effect of moderation of social comparison orientation nor mediation via negative automatic thoughts were shown. Overall, this research provided evidence for the efficacy of CBT-based interventions, such as the SMA program, in reducing the negative impact of HVSNS use on well-being and body satisfaction. While demonstrating usefulness as an accessible stand-alone intervention with immediate benefits, findings from the SMA program may also help to inform the future design of more comprehensive social media literacy programs. Future studies should continue to explore the specific factors that may identify those more likely to respond to the program and the potential impact of other CBT-based strategies.
Author: Herriman, Zoe
Institution: The University of Adelaide
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: social networking sites, cognitive behavioral therapy, social comparison, body image, well-being, negative automatic thoughts, cognitive restructuring, body satisfaction, negative affect, life satisfaction, social comparison orientation, feasibility and acceptability, pilot study, randomized controlled trials
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7217049485
