Work

Supporting PhD physicists through investigations of ethical decision-making and structures of graduate education

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The work represented in this dissertation is intended to support the development of PhD physicists in areas identified as critical to the PER community through established research in the community and from national reports, particularly in ethics education for faculty scientists and physics graduate education.I describe two individual projects that focus on considering different Epistemic Frames that faculty scientists engage in during value-laden discussions and the graduate education of physicists in terms of program requirements and retention measures.Scientists engage with ethical dilemmas regularly.Training modules are developed to instruct scientists to better identify and navigate these dilemmas, but often focus on rules and regulations and not contexts aligned with the needs of scientists.Case-based discussions have been shown to impact ethical decision-making, and part of the Goals and Values in Science project was to investigate the impact that value-laden discussions have on faculty scientists' ethical decisionmaking.In this work, we applied the methodology of identifying epistemic frames to value-laden discussions.We identify three distinct group epistemic frames: Facilitator Frame, Sharing Science Frame, and Arguing Claims Frame.This work provides a foundation towards better understanding how faculty scientists make sense of value-laden discussions and promote productive avenues for designing ethical interventions.The number of PhDs awarded in physics since 1861 has dramatically expanded, sometimes rapidly.To fully understand the potentially diverse set of program requirements and expectations of physics graduate education, we investigated the structures of PhD-granting institutions in the United States.We determined 10 distinct structures of program requirements, including Core Courses, Elective Courses, Comprehensive Content Exams, Research Readiness Exams, The Dissertation, Supervisory Committee, Training, Annual Reports, The Teaching Assistant Requirement, and Presentations of Research.These structures represent the most common practices and requirements of the physics graduate programs investigated.We additionally identified a common
Institution: University of Idaho
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7217645283
Cites: 103
Cited by:
Related to: 10