Work

Enhancing communication and support for autistic and learning-disabled individuals in the criminal justice system

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis provides a comprehensive exploration of the use of special measures and bespoke communication tools to support autistic and learning-disabled individuals in communicating and engaging with the criminal justice system. The methods used include a systematic review, a methodological critique, an empirical research study, and a case study. Chapter One introduces the current literature on the experiences of autistic and learning-disabled individuals’ contact with the criminal justice system. It examines theories of communication in both autism and learning disabilities and the impact that communication barriers have on engagement with the criminal justice system. The chapter identifies existing provisions of support, highlighting gaps that warrant further exploration, which this thesis seeks to address. Chapter Two presents a systematic review synthesising the current evidence on vulnerable witnesses’ experiences of using special measures in the courtroom. The review builds on the challenges identified in Chapter One. Findings from this review suggest that special measures appear to have a positive impact when appropriately implemented. The need for greater intervention to ensure individuals understand questioning during cross-examination, alongside positive views towards the use of intermediaries and communication aids, is recognised. While the systematic review in Chapter Two explores what research exists on special measures, Chapter Three considers how reliable and valid this evidence is, particularly where it stems from jury simulation studies – a dominant methodology underpinning much of the literature in this area. The analysis highlights how methodological choices should align with the nature of the research question (whether legal or psychological), as well as the intended audience (e.g., academic, applied, or policy makers). In response to the gaps identified within the literature, Chapter Four presents an empirical study exploring the influence of autism diagnosis disclosure and supporting information, intermediary support, and their combination on jurors’ attributions of guilt and leniency towards an autistic male defendant. The findings suggest that neither the provision of an autism diagnosis and supporting information, nor the presence of an intermediary, significantly affected whether participants judged the defendant as guilty or not. Similarly, isolated judgements of criminal intention, moral responsibility, and legal responsibility were not strongly influenced by these factors; however, when combined, they did affect the overall pattern of participants’ attributions. Building on the empirical concerns raised in Chapters One through Four, Chapter Five offers a real-world case study describing the practical application of two communication tools – mood cards and a positive behavioural support intervention for a female forensic inpatient diagnosed with a learning disability. The integration of mood cards within the Positive Behaviour Support (PBS) framework for Ms Z represents a diverse, person-centred approach that addresses both communication and behavioural needs holistically. The findings highlight how visual communication tools can enhance the effectiveness of behavioural interventions, demonstrating the core role communication plays, particularly in autistic and learning disability populations. Finally, Chapter Six concludes the thesis. It presents a summary of the findings in Chapters Two through Five. It discusses implications for research and practice, acknowledges strengths and limitations, and critically offers recommendations for future research to advance support for autistic and learning-disabled individuals engaged with the criminal justice system.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7217712380
Cites: 287
Cited by:
Related to: 10