Work

The Anatomy of a Good Eyewitness: Applying Brain Volumetry and the Hippocampal Long-Axis Specialization Theory to Forensic Memory

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: A substantial body of research suggests that the hippocampus is dissociable along its long axis, though the exact nature of this dissociation is far from clear. Some research suggests that the anterior hippocampus may be responsible for gist memory while the posterior hippocampus is responsible for detail. Further, recent unpublished lab data indicates that the larger one of the anterior or posterior segments is, the more participants may structure their recall with gist or detail, respectively. Simultaneously, research on eyewitness testimony has largely neglected both individual differences-focused approaches and neuroscientific methods. Because some research indicates that gist memory is more susceptible to misinformation, a mediation model was devised to explore whether the previous findings could be replicated and extended in a forensic context. The current pilot experiment investigated whether hippocampal head/tail volumes would predict gist- or detail-first approaches to memory, and whether memory style would in turn predict misinformation acceptance. 56 participants were shown 5 narrated slideshows depicting minor crimes or otherwise forensically relevant incidents. They then listened to what they were led to believe was an expert’s recall. 1 week later, they filled out a questionnaire with questions testing for accuracy and probing for misinformation acceptance. Broadly, the previous findings that (a) participants varied meaningfully in their gist- or detail-first styles of memory was not replicated, nor was the finding that (b) gist memory was more susceptible to misinformation. Although the experiment was not fully powered, every arm of the mediation model was non-significant. However, PLS analyses suggested that hippocampal subregions nonetheless participated in broader brain networks that were implicated in a variety of memory functions, such as cholinergic memory modulation and cognitive monitoring.
Institution: Queen's University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7217766437
Cites: 67
Cited by:
Related to: 10