Year: 2023
Type: report
Abstract: Recommendation 4: Deinstitutionalise and Desegregate .It is recommended that governments in Australia commit to full deinstitutionalisation and desegregation of the living environments of people with disability .Research indicates that to facilitate full deinstitutionalisation of people with disability, there must be a commitment to deinstitutionalisation, a change in attitudes towards people with disability, community development that enables full inclusion and participation of people with disability, as well as a rights-based and transformative policy shift towards housing .It is further recommended that governments address segregation of environments beyond housing that people with disability also find themselves within.This means ending segregation in systems that currently only apply to people with disability such as 'special' or segregated schools, Australian Disability Enterprises (ADEs), group homes, day centres, and mental health facilities .Ending segregation of people with disability would align with violence prevention and safety enhancement approaches identified in the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse . Recommendation 5: Recognise the autonomy of people with disability .It is recommended that governments in Australia respect and protect the autonomy of people with disability to make decisions about what happens to their bodies and lives .This recommendation for autonomy is consistent with obligations outlined in the CRPD, particularly Article 12 on equality before the law, and Article 19 on independent living and community inclusion, as well as Article 21 on freedom of expression and opinion, Article 29 on participation in political and public life, and general principles in Article 3 .Enhancing the autonomy of people with disability in relation to First Nations people with disability needs to be understood in the broader context of Indigenous and First Nations self-determination and nation-building . Recommendation 6: Utilise trauma-informed support approaches .Restrictive practices are traumatic .It is recommended that governments in Australia facilitate trauma-informed approaches to service-delivery, particularly within the human services sector .This recommendation is consistent with the obligations outlined in Article 16 of the CRPD .the present-day existence and/or wealth of the perpetrators .From a human rights perspective, a redress scheme is particularly significant because it can redress all human rights violations irrespective of whether they were unlawful under domestic law .A redress scheme should operate alongside court remedies, and access to one should not prevent access to the other .Attention must also be paid to improving access to justice in the criminal and civil justice systems for victim-survivors of restrictive practices .a nationally consistent legislative and administrative framework for the protection of all persons with disabilities, including children, from the use of psychotropic medications, physical restraints and seclusion under the guise of "behaviour modification" and the elimination of restrictive practices, including corporal punishment, in all settings, including the home .10 This recommendation by the UN Committee on Rights of Persons with Disabilities aligns directly with the recommendation made by Disabled People's Organisations in Australia . 11The recommendation is thus representative of the views and goals of people with disability themselves .Despite the strong condemnation of use of restrictive practices by Disabled People's Organisations and the international human rights community, there has not been significant progress in Australia towards prohibition and elimination of these practices .Instead, some forms of restrictive practices are authorised and regulated .Under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Restrictive Practices and Behaviour Support) Rules 2018, the following forms of restrictive practices are listed as subject to regulation:• Seclusion: 'the sole confinement of a person with disability in a room or a physical space at any hour of the day or night where voluntary exit is prevented, or not facilitated, or it is implied that voluntary exit is not permitted .' 12Lastly, these practices are at issue because they are at odds with, and significantly violate the human rights of people with disability because of the nature of the practices (that is, potentially as torture and ill-treatment), their discriminatory application, and the legal and other barriers which prevent equal access to justice and remedy for violence, torture and ill-treatment .We engage further with the human rights of people with disability in the next Chapter, Chapter 1 .
Authors: Spivakovsky, C, Steele, L, Wadiwel, D
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: restrictive practices, deinstitutionalization, desegregation, people with disabilities, autonomy, Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, trauma-informed services, access to justice, psychotropic drugs, physical restraint, seclusion, corporal punishment, disability rights policy, Australia, Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, mental health facilities
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7218328231
