The cost of gaps in existing food price-stabilizing market policies in urban areas for poor women and their families: The case of Addis Ababa
Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Food inflation has been a challenge in Ethiopia since prices of staple foods started rising in 2005, particularly threatening the food security of relatively poor and marginalized groups, such as women.However, there is limited research on the actual impact of food price surges and government-responsive programs on poor women.This study investigates the effect of food inflation and its coping mechanisms vis-à-vis government response programs from the perspective of poor women through consciously adopting feminist economics as a theoretical and interpretive framework.This was accomplished by taking into consideration women's gender-based privations and other facets of their identities and lived realities.It employed a qualitative methodology that is guided by feminist epistemological principles in its design including data collection and analysis techniques.It investigated and drew lessons from how poor women are impacted by and cope with food inflation in relation to the Public Distribution System (PDS) of basic goods in Addis Ababa, a government intervention program, using the case study approach.In-depth interviews (IDIs) and two rounds of focus group discussions, (FGDs) utilizing Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA) tools were carried out for women beneficiaries of the program, selected through the snowball sample technique, respectively.IDIs were also conducted for government and private implementing institutions of the intervention program.The study assessed food provisioning strategies alongside an experience-based food insecurity measure to capture the many manifestations of women's vulnerability to increases in food prices.It also adopted a theory-based evaluation to assess the effectiveness of the intervention program's execution and achievement of its targeted goals, as well as a feminist analytic framework to analyse how well it catered for the gendered needs and constraints.The findings revealed that time poverty, inadequate education, and lack of access to resources like income and assets constitute some of the main gendered and interrelated challenges poor women in the study area must overcome.https://etd.uwc.ac.za/V The impact of the time poverty brought on by poor women's numerous responsibilities and the absence of viable alternatives to their labour manifests in several ways.These include the strain on women's bodies and minds as well as the pressure to prioritize one role over another, which has long-term impacts on them, such as lowered competitiveness in the job market.This is primarily explained by gender ideals, which have obligated them to ensure the families' long-term survival regardless of their other duties and have denied them the negotiating leverage to access the family's assets and income including their earnings.Women are forced to bear disproportionally higher levels of emotional, monetary, and time costs of food inflation due to these gendered privations that significantly restrict their capacity to cope.Although impoverished women buy less expensive food to cope, these cheaper foods typically take longer to buy, cook, or do both.In times of food inflation, poor women are faced with the hard decision of either suffering from food insecurity or committing more of their effort and time to food purchase and preparation.Despite being the only legal source of subsidised basic goods for the targeted beneficiaries, a theory-driven evaluation of the PDS of basic goods found that it had not succeeded in shielding its intended beneficiaries from rising food costs or ensuring that they consistently had access to basic goods at discounted rates.This is demonstrated in how the targeted beneficiaries continued to buy their food in the open or parallel market/illegal market where they have no protection from the PDS against exorbitant prices.This was traced to implementation problems and faulty assumptions embedded in the program theory including the needs of its targeted beneficiaries and ways of addressing them, and the capacity of the implementing institutions to execute the program as adequately as planned.Despite facilitating access to basic goods to its poor women beneficiaries, the PDS has failed to meet their specific demands in terms of product characteristics such as quality scale/volume, and time.This was attributed to the intervention's androcentric orientation, evidenced by its disregard for women's gender-specific needs and challenges and its inability to address the issue through their experiences while taking into account their hidden/private transaction costs.https://etd.uwc.ac.za/VI Despite the intervention's effort to maintain its gender neutrality, it relied on the extra time and effort provided by women in procuring and cooking food to compensate for its inefficiencies, worsening their existing reproductive burdens and widening gender disparities.
Author: Tefera, Tsega Girma
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7219200173
