Toward a Philosophical Biology: Principles and Parameters for Mechanistic Explanations in Cell Biology
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The scope of this dissertation concerns the philosophical underpinnings of explanations in biology, with a particular focus on cell biology. It begins by posing a problem: current explanatory practices in cell biology, which are by and large mechanistic, appear to be facing challenges in capturing the full complexity and augmenting our understanding of various normal and disease cellular phenomena. While considerable descriptive mechanistic detail continues to be discovered, much remains to be further uncovered conceptually concerning the biological cell. Starting with this premise, the thesis makes a two-pronged proposal: (i) to improve mechanistic explanations in and of themselves (and make them more complete) by explicating in greater depth part–part interactions, and (ii) to bring into the explanatory mix cell-biology-relevant laws or generalisations to better explain different facets of a given mechanistic explanation, by for instance helping to answer why-this-and-not-that types of questions concerning the parts or interactions in the mechanistic explanation. To do so, the dissertation draws several lessons from the recent history of mechanistic and law-based explanations in the philosophy of science. It then devotes a chapter to developing a new theoretical framework to examine part–part interactions in a cellular mechanism, followed by a chapter focused on the concept of cell-biological generalisations and their inclusion in cell biology explanations. This latter chapter proposes to distinguish between cell-biological ‘laws’ vs. ‘principles’ based on the criteria of broadness of scope and precision of predictions, a practical framework that may aid in the discovery of novel generalisations in cell biology. Lastly, these theoretical concepts are applied in a case-study chapter centred on the pathobiology of Alzheimer’s disease, which attempts to crystallise the philosophical discussion of the thesis using a current research topic in cell-biological practice.
Author: Ehsani, Sepehr
Language: English
Subfield: History and Philosophy of Science
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7219234647
