Work

A Digital Innovation Adoption Framework for Kenyan Family-Owned Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs)

Year: 2025
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: The importance of micro-, small- and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs) to the economies of countries is well established globally and in Africa. Ninety percent of all businesses in Africa are classified as MSMEs, with the majority being family-owned. Given the accelerating pace of digitalisation currently taking place in the global business environment, there is an urgent need to understand and support the digitalisation of these businesses. To maintain their competitive relevance, family- owned MSMEs must develop the capabilities to respond to the onset of digitisation and the required digital innovations. A reluctance on the part of family businesses to adopt innovation in general has, however, been observed. This reluctance has, in part, been attributed to the socioemotional need of family businesses to align their family’s non-financial, and often emotional, priorities with innovation decisions. Another reason for this reluctance to adopt digital innovations, is because of the existence of the willingness-ability paradox present in family businesses. However, a lack of innovation, and specifically innovation using digital technologies, could threaten the sustainability of family businesses as a growing number of consumers are inclined to be drawn to the use of digital savvy products and services offered through a digital business environment. Therefore, this study aimed to develop a digital innovation adoption (DIA) framework for Kenyan family-owned MSMEs, which would enable them to improve innovation in their businesses and, in turn, increase the satisfaction of their customers and the success of their businesses. The technological, organisational and environmental (TOE) framework, as well as the socioemotional wealth (SEW) theory, served as the theoretical lenses underpinning the DIA framework developed in this study. The TOE framework elucidates the factors influencing technology adoption decisions in organisations and identifies three broad categories, namely, technological, environmental and organisational. The theory of SEW posits that decisions made by family business owners and managers, including decisions related to innovation, are motivated by the family’s commitment to preserving their SEW, which refers to the non-financial aspects or priorities of the family business. As a result, a hypothesised model was developed for empirical testing. The proposed hypothesised model included several technological, vi organisational, environmental and family-specific factors as influencing DIA in Kenyan family-owned MSMEs. In addition, the moderating influence of SEW on these relationships were also hypothesised. Furthermore, direct relationships between SEW and DIA, as well as between DIA and Perceived financial performance, were hypothesised. Positioned in the positivist research paradigm, a deductive approach to theory development was used for the study, while the methodological choice was that of a mono-method quantitative orientation. A cross-sectional time horizon and a survey research strategy were adopted. To collect the data, an online survey was administered using a structured questionnaire. A sample was drawn from a large database of Kenyan MSMEs and a total of 355 respondents, who were identified through convenience and snowball sampling, completed the questionnaire. Descriptive and inferential statistics, notably structural equation modelling, were undertaken to analyse the data. Based on the empirical results in this study, the DIA framework developed highlighted that certain technological factors, Compatibility and Cost, organisational factors, Top management support and Organisational readiness, environmental factors, External pressure and External DT support, as well as family-specific factors, Inward-looking attitude of the family and Conservative attitude of the family, influenced DIA in family- owned MSMEs. SEW was also found to influence DIA, and moderate the influence of Compatibility and Top management support on DIA. In turn, DIA was found to influence the Perceived financial performance of Kenyan family-owned MSMEs. The findings highlighted the influence of the family’s non-financial, emotional priorities on innovation decisions and the importance of innovation using digital technologies for long-term business success. Several recommendations for Kenyan family-owned MSMEs on how to enhance DIA occurring in their businesses were put forward. Implementing these recommendations could help to ensure the long-term sustainability of family-owned businesses and preserve family legacies. The overall contribution of this study was that it addressed a crucial gap in the extant literature by combining the TOE framework’s rational technology adoption paradigm with SEW's influence to provide a more comprehensive vii understanding of DIA occurring in family-owned MSMEs. This study proposes referring to the adapted TOE framework for family businesses as the TOE+F(family) framework.
Author: MUTURA, R
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7220773716
FWCI:
Cites: 546
Cited by:
Related to: 10