Work

An exploration of the Participatory Guarantee System (PGS). Assessing the role it plays in facilitating the growth and certification of small-scale organic farmers: Giyani, Garden Route and Overberg case studies.

Year: 2023
Type: article
Abstract: In this study, I evaluated the Participatory Guarantee System (PGS) as a framework to support the growth and certification of small-scale organic farmers. I used the interpretivism and constructivism lenses to understand the PGS from the perspective of members of three PGS groups. The research was qualitative, treating the three PGS groups as case studies. I collected data using focus groups, semi-structured interviews, questionnaires, field notes and observations. The theoretical frameworks that guided the research and data analysis were Socio-ecological Systems (SES) based principles and the Multi-Level-Perspective (MLP) framework. The data were analysed using Atlas.ti content analysis software. The key results were grouped into four themes: capacity; market and logistics; learning process; and disturbance, shock and stress. The theme of ‘capacity’ dealt with the functioning of a PGS, where three categories were identified: group composition and capacity; resource limitations and institutional support; marketing and consumer education. The more diversity in age, education and culture of PGS stakeholders, the better performance and chances of continuity and propagation. PGS has limited capacity partly due to its voluntary nature and infancy. It needs institutional support to grow and be useful for members. Department of Agriculture extension officers knew little about organic farming, thus limiting their engagement and assistance to such farmers. The theme of ‘market and logistics’ looked at the various factors that influence the farmers’ market reach. The perception from the members was that there was minimal consumer awareness about organic agriculture and the PGS. The marketing of organic produce relied largely on the individual farmer’s efforts and ability to search for and secure markets. The theme of the ‘learning process’ was categorised into learning and knowledge exchange. Members of the PGS groups highly regarded the invaluable knowledge shared through farm visits and online platforms, such as their WhatsApp groups. This knowledge improved and informed their farming techniques and led to the growth of iv their skill base and experimentation. They viewed the way knowledge was exchanged as non-threatening and highly useful. The fourth theme of ‘disturbance, shock and stress’ dealt with the effects of COVID- 19. The three groups were all affected by lockdown restrictions (at the time of data collection) and were initially cut off from their usual markets. This led to a loss of income, loss of farm staff and a loss of the desired growth of the farms. The group’s diverse farming practices bolstered their resilience, enabling them to adapt and try alternative marketing strategies. The PGS framework facilitates the growth and certification of small-scale organic farmers. It offers a platform for experimentation and innovations amongst members and the diverse practices used to increase its resilience. However, PGS is still young and lacks institutional support to firmly establish itself. The following recommendations emanate from the study: 1) PGS requires context-specific support systems and collaboration to be fully effective for the building and capacity development of the members; 2) PGS members need to build networks actively with agricultural extension services and local government agencies. This may facilitate communication with agricultural practitioners and aid the learning process needed by government officials and agencies to better understand organic farming and possibly lead to collaborative and transformative actions. Collaborative action between industrial and organic agriculture has the potential to foster a slow but continuous transformation of the food system. Furthermore, it will be instrumental in improving extension knowledge of organic farming practices. Future research looking at how socio-cultural factors influence the development and progress of a PGS group would be beneficial. Research into PGS groups should prioritise face-to-face interviews in the form of farm visits. This opportunity allows the farmers to showcase their work and produces a wealth of insight, as compared to questionnaires and surveys. v
Author: Mashele, N
Language: English
Subfield: Plant Science
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7220773850
FWCI:
Cites: 99
Cited by:
Related to: 9