Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: International migration is transforming the labour markets and social security systems of high-income countries. Net immigration drives population growth in Finland, with more than one in 10 employed individuals now being migrants. The native share in the working-age population is decreasing due to aging and low fertility rates. This makes migrants’ long-term employment prospects more crucial to the fiscal sustainability of the welfare state and to the maintenance of an adequate labour supply. When health issues cause migrants to leave the labour market early – whether through earnings losses, extended sick leave, or disability pensions – Finland loses valuable workers and sees an increase in the number of benefit recipients. This undermines the economic justification for labour migration. Although research on migrant labour market integration has extensively studied obstacles to employment – such as limited recognition of foreign qualifications, language barriers, and discrimination – the economic impacts of health shocks and indicators of work incapacity, including sickness absence and disability pensions, have also been explored in various contexts. However, research on how health affects migrants’ long-term work ability and work participation, and how occupational class determines these outcomes, remains scarce, particularly in Finland. To address these knowledge gaps, this dissertation shifts the focus from labour market entry to the sustainability of employment, examining how health-related career disruptions determine migrants’ long-term labour market outcomes and whether Finland’s universal welfare system provides equal protection when health deteriorates. The dissertation offers new evidence in three areas. First, it provides the first population-wide analysis of migrant–native earnings differences following acute health shocks. Second, it examines how occupational class and diagnostic groups shape patterns of sickness absence differently for migrants and natives over a 15 year period. Third, it presents the first Finnish register-based study of disability pension risk among migrants, including the role of occupational class. The dissertation develops an integrated framework that combines health and disability research, labour market stratification theory, and administrative burden theory. To explain how migrants’ structural occupational positions influence their health related labour market outcomes, this framework, drawing on and extending existing literature, identifies three mechanisms: differential exposure, differential buffering, and differential gatekeeping. The analyses of the dissertation studies were based on high-quality, full population administrative register data from 2005 to 2019. Study I employs a dynamic difference-in-differences event-study approach with entropy balancing. Study II analyses age-adjusted sickness absence prevalence and, using modified Poisson regression models with a log link function, it estimates risk ratios by occupational class, diagnostic group, and time. Study III uses Cox proportional hazards models to estimate the risk of receiving disability pensions among migrants and natives. In Study I, it was observed that health shocks resulted in substantial and persistent earnings losses. Overall, migrants lost 13.5% of their yearly earnings, compared with 7.4% for natives. Migrant men experienced the largest penalty at 17.7%, roughly twice that of migrant women (8.6%). Among migrants, those from European and Western countries as well as those from Russia or the former Soviet Union, experienced the most significant earnings declines. Social benefits compensated roughly half of natives’ earnings losses but only a third of migrants’ losses, indicating that Finland’s welfare state better buffers natives’ earnings. Study II found that, unlike earlier research from Sweden and Norway, migrants in Finland had lower sickness absence prevalence than natives across all diagnostic groups and throughout the study period. Occupational disparities in sickness absences were clear, especially among migrants, and they grew over time. By 2019, unemployed migrant men had the highest risk of all-cause (RR 2.56) and mental disorder-related sickness absence (RR 2.60) within their own group, and a risk comparable to that of manual workers for musculoskeletal sickness absence (RR 4.45). Over time, migrant men experienced a higher increase in the risk of mental disorders-related sickness absence compared to women. Study III found that migrants, compared to natives, had a lower risk of receiving a disability pension. The analysis indicated a 37% higher risk for migrants from refugee-origin countries and a 30% higher risk for those from other non-European countries compared to natives. Among all migrants, the risk of a disability pension was increased with longer residence in Finland. Differences in occupational class significantly influenced the risk of receiving a disability pension for both migrants and natives, but the gap between migrants and natives in the risk was not fully explained by occupational class. The findings of the dissertation suggested that health-related labour market disadvantages among migrants may not originate from migrant status itself but from the structurally shaped occupational positions they tend to occupy in segmented labour markets that are characterized by physically demanding work, job insecurity, and unequal access to welfare institutions. Despite Finland’s universal welfare state system, formal rights do not guarantee equal protection in practice. The dissertation concludes that long-term health-related labour market outcomes are best understood through the lens of sustainability, that is, the capacity to maintain work and earnings when health problems arise. Policy responses should target the occupational health gap within Finland’s three-channel healthcare system, adapt return-to-work tools for non-full-time jobs, and broaden integration monitoring to incorporate health-related metrics.
Source: UTUPub (University of Turku)
Author: Haider, Waseem
Language: English
Topic: Migration and Labor Dynamics
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7220777438
