The management of electoral violence through preventive diplomacy: lessons learned from Burundi
Year: 2022
Type: article
Abstract: Burundi’s 2015 electoral crisis is representative of how the use of constitutional manipulation to extend the incumbent’s terms in office has emerged as a trigger for electoral violence. Burundi’s history of intractable and ethnic conflict meant that this episode of electoral violence had the potential to escalate into prolonged armed violence. Electoral violence has been a recurring challenge for Africa, with the subsequent threat to continental stability. Hence, this study aimed to examine the potential utility of multi-track preventive diplomacy to implement inclusive electoral violence prevention initiatives by examining continental regional interventions in Burundi between 2014 and 2018. The study adopted a qualitative case study research approach within the interpretivist philosophical perspective. The study utilised data collected from 35 semi-structured interviews and a documentary review of 141 secondary data sources. The study’s findings indicate that the interaction between the formulation and implementation of multi-track diplomacy was guided by the normative framework in which policy instruments are implemented. This includes the African Union and East African Community’s preference for consensual interventions over coercive measures and the salience of the principle of subsidiarity. The study also finds that several factors impeded the impact of continental and regional multi-track preventive diplomacy. These factors included the lack of strategic coordination, the lack of a common position on term limit extensions, regional tensions, Burundi’s refusal to cooperate with initiatives, and the lack of established regional frameworks to engage with civil society and grassroots actors in Burundi. The study contributed to the literature on preventing electoral violence by concluding that the continent’s current normative and institutional frameworks impede the utility of multitrack preventive diplomacy in authoritarian contexts. This is because the African Union and regional organisations prefer consensual interventions and are averse to using coercive instruments. Hence, authoritarian governments like those in Burundi’s case study can restrict the political space, which subsequently affects the participation of non-state actors in multitrack interventions. Additionally, the study contributed to the literature on electoral violence prevention by noting that APSA’s current normative and institutional frameworks impedes multi-track preventive diplomacy from potentially acting as the nexus point between conflict prevention and the promotion of democratisation. The study concludes that multi-track preventive diplomacy conducted at the regional level lacked the support from APSA’s decision-making structures to ensure that it contributed to the high-level engagement and longer-term democratisation processes. The study therefore recommends that the African Union and regional organisations must take a pre-emptive approach to electoral governance. The first way this can be done is by strengthening the prohibitions surrounding presidential term extensions through constitutional manipulation by clarifying the language in policy instruments. Secondly, this can be done by ensuring that officials in the political affairs departments at the regional and continental levels take a proactive stance of engaging with the electoral management bodies of their member states before elections are held.,Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Humanities, School of Governmental and Social Sciences, 2022
Author: Mutangadura, Chido Samantha
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: electoral violence, preventive diplomacy, multi-track diplomacy, presidential term limits, African Union, East African Community, conflict prevention, democratization, authoritarianism, regional organizations, subsidiarity, election administration, civil society participation, APSA, ethnic conflict, non-state actors
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7220780402
