Cognitive bias in the rubric evaluation of student performance in standards-based grading models
Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Over the past decades, alternative grading models that rely on teachers' professional judgment of the quality of student work have been embraced as a more equitable method for grading since they claim to provide more specific, timely, and personalized feedback on students' knowledge and growth (Buckmiller et al., 2017;Knight & Cooper, 2019;Muñoz, & Guskey, 2015).These models include competency-based grading, portfolio-based grading, and standardsbased grading, with standards-based grading being more widely practiced than the others (Buckmiller et al., 2020;Erickson, 2011;Iamarino, 2014).Proponents of standards-based grading argue that it is less subject to cognitive and racial biases of teachers than conventional grading systems (Feldman, 2019; Quinn, 2020).This study scrutinized this claim by investigating whether standards-based grading models resisted such teacher biases.Specifically, this study investigated racial discrimination, shifted standard bias, and expectancy bias using the quantitative approach of a factorial vignette experiment.Additionally, qualitative feedback to students about their performance was analyzed regarding teachers' attributions for student performance.The findings of this study suggest that using a standards-based rubric to grade and essay did not activate any racial bias; however, expectation bias, a shifted mastery standard, and attribution error were present.
Author: Reibel, Anthony R
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7220783408
