Legitimacy dynamics and sustainability transitions: A Palm Oil governance case in Liberia 2008–2025
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Companies operating in land-use sectors such as palm oil agribusiness are the subject of considerable controversy regarding their social, environmental and economic sustainability. Firms, particularly in the Global South, face complex challenges in establishing and maintaining the legitimacy of their activities across local, national and global contexts. These organisations frequently operate alongside vulnerable communities and within layered institutional arrangements that combine national regulatory systems, transnational sustainability standards and civil society advocacy. In the palm oil sector, a central governance forum is the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), a multi-stakeholder initiative that establishes principles and criteria for certified sustainable palm oil and provides procedures for dispute resolution and complaints regarding compliance. This dissertation examines tensions that arise between competing interpretations of sustainability and development and between the interests of companies, communities, non-governmental organisations and other stakeholders. Prior research has shown that communities, companies, NGOs and governance organisations exercise different forms of agency, while community positions may also enter national and transnational governance through intermediary actors. At the same time, companies and governance initiatives such as the RSPO seek more legitimate modes of producing sustainable palm oil. These dynamics raise important questions regarding how legitimacy is constructed, contested and maintained across multiple actors and governance arenas. This doctoral dissertation aims to analyse these legitimacy problem spaces through different perspectives on legitimacy to understand legitimacy dynamics in sustainability transitions. It uses the longitudinal legitimacy process surrounding Golden Veroleum Liberia (GVL), particularly contestation over whether Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) had been achieved in its operations in the Republic of Liberia, as its empirical case. More specifically, it examines how land-adjacent organisations interpret and respond to legitimacy challenges, where, how and through whom processes of legitimation and de-legitimation occur, and how the spaces in which legitimacy is constructed or contested are configured during sustainability transitions. The dissertation adopts a longitudinal qualitative research design centred on an in-depth case study of the GVL FPIC/RSPO contestation. The empirical analysis 4 focuses primarily on the period from 2008 to 2020, while tracing developments in the governance and legitimacy dynamics surrounding the project through to 2025. Data include participant observation and organisational working material, interviews with company, government and civil-society participants, and extensive documentary evidence from RSPO complaint procedures and related governance processes. This longitudinal approach enables the reconstruction of legitimacy dynamics across time and provides an inside perspective on how company actors interpreted and responded to interactions with communities, civil society organisations and transnational governance institutions. Building on recent scholarship conceptualising legitimacy as property, perception and process, the dissertation develops the legitimacy process-space framework for analysing legitimacy dynamics across time, place and space. The analysis shows that legitimacy challenges in the GVL case unfolded across multiple overlapping process spaces in which different actors advanced competing interpretations of sustainability, accountability and development. The framework provides a way to analyse how actors, forms of agency and legitimacy outcomes are configured across and between these spaces. In the case, legitimacy outcomes were shaped not only by institutional structures but also by the strategic and interpretive agency of actors operating within and across them. The empirical analysis traces four phases in the evolution of legitimacy dynamics beginning in 2008: an initial period of anticipatory legitimacy associated with development expectations; a phase of expanding scrutiny as the project became embedded within transnational sustainability governance; a period of intensified contestation marked by community conflict and formal grievances; and a later phase characterised by renewed contestation, attempts to stabilise governance outcomes and eventual formal closure of the RSPO complaints process in 2025. The findings show that legitimacy in the GVL case did not converge towards a single shared judgement. Instead, legitimacy processes fragmented across different stakeholder groups and governance arenas, producing parallel and sometimes conflicting legitimacy trajectories. Legitimacy that stabilised in one process space did not necessarily transfer to others, while formal closure of the RSPO process coexisted with continuing contestation elsewhere. By providing a longitudinal inside perspective on palm oil agribusiness and developing the legitimacy process-space framework, the dissertation contributes to organisational legitimacy and sustainability-transitions research by showing how legitimacy can be analysed as a spatially differentiated process unfolding across time, place and space.
Source: UTUPub (University of Turku)
Author: Karinen, Matti
Language: English
Subfield: Ecology
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: Turun Yliopisto
OpenAlex ID: W7220792738
