Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis was informed by what I perceived to be a tense relationship between Western biomedical science and, for example, "traditional" or "indigenous" ways of producing knowledge about medicinal plants used to manage a pervasive condition like Tuberculosis (TB) in South Africa.Hoping to reimagine this relationship and its possibilities, I follow medicinal plants collected from Genadendal through three research spaces with disparate but intertwined knowledge heritages to investigate these tensions but also to tease out how knowledge about locally used medicinal plants is generated and "done" in practice.The first space was at the South African Herbal Science and Medicines Institute (SAHMI) as part of an experiential science project led by scientists who were interested in studying medicinal plants which could potentially provide new sources of safe, affordable, and sustainable medicine for communicable conditions such as TB.The second was at the Genadendal clinic and Home-Based-Care Unit (HBCU) where I examined TB as a disease that is diagnosed, defined and "done" in and through medical practice.Thirdly, I collected medicinal plants and spent time doing long term ethnographic fieldwork with kruiekenners and medicinal plant users in Genadendal to explore how TB, as an illness, is understood, managed, and handled differently in and through local knowledge and daily sociomaterial practices, such as through lay diagnostics and the use of plant medicines.As the project and my own ethnographic research progressed, there were certain parallels and points of divergence to be drawn from the ways in which different "actors" produce knowledge about medicinal plants (kruie).This was especially evident in practice when I followed medicinal plants, and to a certain extent TB, through their various entanglements with humans, technology, experiential techniques, TB tests, etc.In the thesis, the aim is not to make comparisons but to foreground the complex relations that exist between scientists, kruiekenners, plant users and plants by offering an account of the kinds of conversations which occurred between these groups and their respective plant practices.Drawing on the seminal work of Latour and Mol, and on trends in the literature on more-than-human or other-than-human approaches to studying plants, I argue for an alternative configuration of knowledge objects such as kruie, TB, and experiential science; one which is conscious of the authority of science and medical practice, but which is also inclusive of kruiekenners knowledge and sufferer's figurations of illness, aetiologies, stigma, treatment and healing.I also argue for a critical rethinking of the way plants have been approached as objectives of the natural world.
Author: Davids, Denver
Institution: University of the Western Cape
Language: English
Subfield: Plant Science
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7220793869
