Work

Collaborative governance to mitigate policy implementation failure: an exploration of selected municipalities in Amathole region, Eastern Cape Province

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This study investigated challenges contributing to the recurring failure of public policy implementation by focusing on the Cooperative Development Policy of South Africa. The collaborative governance theory was adopted to guide the investigation. The investigation included selected municipalities in the Amathole region in the Eastern Cape Province as they implement policies for cooperative projects in this region. These municipalities encompass the Amathole District Municipality, as well as Mbhashe, Mnquma, and Ngqushwa local municipalities. The investigation comprised (a) partner organisations, such as national and provincial public institutions and the private sector institutions that work collaboratively with the municipalities to develop projects; (b) diverse stakeholders, such as consulting agencies, ward councillors, the development trust, and projects. Constructivism was adopted as the study’s school of thought to enable the use of qualitative research methods during the data collection process. Qualitative research methods made it possible to collect in-depth details from participants about their experience on challenges that perpetuate policy implementation failure. The data collection involved conducting individual interviews with 24 participants, namely, officials from public and private sector institutions, as well as a diverse array of stakeholders. Interviews were also conducted with participants from two focus groups. The study findings uncovered that municipalities develop the capacity of cooperative projects by inviting diverse organisations on information sessions in municipal areas, to advise projects about the types of business development interventions they offer to them. Municipalities work collaboratively with government development agencies, government departments, and other stakeholders, to assist cooperative projects to market their products or services, and to gain access to funding, for instance, from mining organisations. Amongst the benefits of working collaboratively involve joint contribution with financial and non-financial resources on cooperative projects, and the identification of unique business sectors, such as the bees industry. The findings also disclosed that there are challenges that emerge from relationships and interactions of partner organisations. They include the red tape and political conflicts in municipalities that result in delays in implementing collaborative work activities, and insufficient consultation between the national and provincial public institution officials and municipal officials, when planning and implementing projects in municipal areas. The diversity of policies utilised by these partner organisations duplicates the financial and non-financial support they offer to some projects, while others receive no support. The organisations that provide the support are located in urban areas far away from the projects, while the projects are primarily in rural areas away from urban hubs. Consequently, this support becomes inaccessible to the majority of projects. Thus, to effectively implement the policies, collaborative work among partner organisations must be strengthened through improving communication between partner organisation officials, integrating partner organisation policies for developing projects, and making the support more accessible to the intended beneficiaries.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7220824128
Cites: 432
Cited by:
Related to: 10