Everyday heritage in redevelopment: Reading attribute-based value claims and conflicts in KTT Nguyen Cong Tru, Hanoi, Vietnam
Year: 2026
Type: report
Abstract: Hanoi's socialist collective living quarters (khu tập thể, KTT), built between 1954 and 1986, are the object of an accelerating redevelopment programme justified almost entirely by physical deterioration and safety.This text asks which attributes of a KTT are valued, by whom, and where those valuations collide, using KTT Nguyễn Công Trứ as a deep case.The estate is analytically revealing because redevelopment there is not a prospect but a partially realised fact: a detailed plan was approved in 2009, and its first high-rise block, N3, was completed in 2016 while most of the original fabric still stands.The analysis combines a spatial reading of the estate with a theory-informed, deductive-inductive Framework Analysis of 262 coded interview segments from residents, an outside user, experts and a focus group, and a first reading of the legal instruments that govern redevelopment.The framework treats heritage as a field of value claims, organised by a Value Cube and by three stakeholder-anchored values: use value, expert heritage value, and exchange value in its financial and political dimensions.The analysis identifies five configurations of value, centred on extensions and the ground floor, courtyards and trees, attachment, self-management, and residents' mastery over their dwelling, and shows that residents hold financial and political claims of their own rather than heritage claims alone.It indicates that the attributes residents value most are relational rather than architectural, that they depend on a form of self-management which neither the old municipal regime nor the new building-management model provides for, and that the legal framework separates heritage recognition from the demolition procedure applied to apartment buildings.The text argues that the deterioration invoked to justify demolition is a co-produced condition, and that the redevelopment debate is best understood as a competition between rival futuremaking claims.
Author: Bùi, Phương Ngọc
Language: English
Subfield: Archeology (arts and humanities)
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7220870016
