Evaluation of the Implementation ofAdaptive Design Strategies in Selected Ferry and Bus Terminals in Lagos State
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This mixed-method multiple-case study evaluates climate-adaptive design in three transport terminals in Lagos State: CMS Ferry Terminal, Oshodi Bus Terminal, and Five Cowries Ferry Terminal, and translates the findings into a design framework for futurecoastal transport infrastructure. Evidence was drawn from repeated field observation, photographic documentation, a 24-item structured observation checklist, a physically administered commuter questionnaire, and in-person semi-structured interviews withseven architecture/built environment professionals. The observations show that basic flood-response measures such as raised floors and drainage were visible across the cases, whereas dedicated shading, corrosion protection, inclusive circulation, and responsive technologies were uneven. A domain-level tally of the 24-item checklist shows CMS meeting only 17% of features fully, against 58% at Oshodi and 75% at Five Cowries, confirming CMS as the greatest concentration of deficiencies; Oshodi performed more strongly in spatial organisation and visible flood-resilience provisions; and Five Cowries showed the broadest recorded combination ofcoastal-resilience, wayfinding, and technological features, although no terminal demonstrated a comprehensive adaptive system. The compiled commuter-analysis record identifies thermal comfort as a recurring weakness, acoustic comfort as comparatively the weakest-rated domain overall, and reports comparatively stronger wayfinding at the more formally organised terminals. Expert interviews consistently identified flooding, saline corrosion, heat/humidity, maintenance weaknesses, and the absence of formal post-occupancy feedback as major resilience concerns. Benchmarking against international precedents (Singapore, Sydney, New York,Rotterdam) shows that the strategies missing locally, namely dedicated adjustable shading, tidal-adaptive walkways, integrated smart drainage, and post-disaster resilience upgrades, are already standard practice in comparable coastal-terminal contexts elsewhere. The study proposes a five-tier climate-adaptive terminal model covering flood-safe structure, passive comfort, material durability, inclusivespatial planning, and responsive technologies, with post-occupancy evaluation as a cross-cutting feedback mechanism.
Author: A. A. Adewale
Institution: Covenant University
Language: English
Subfield: Architecture
Field: Engineering
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7221259098
