Thinking Beyond Bias: The Confirmation Bias Index and the Cognitive–Motivational Predictors of Accurate Headline Evaluation
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Confirmation bias — the tendency to favor belief-consistent information over contradictory evidence — represents a central challenge in contemporary misinformation research, yet its behavioral measurement has remained inconsistent across studies. This study introduced the Confirmation Bias Index (CBI), a preregistered behavioral measure defined as the difference in accuracy between ideologically congruent and incongruent headline evaluations. Using a 3 (headline slant: Conservative, Neutral, Liberal) × 2 (veracity: True, False) within-participants design, 198 participants evaluated 36 validated news headlines for accuracy. Results supported a veracity main effect and a reliable group-level confirmation bias effect indexed by the CBI. Headline slant alone did not impair accuracy. Need for Cognition failed to predict overall accuracy or CBI magnitude. Age emerged as the strongest individual-difference predictor, with older participants outperforming younger ones. Findings suggest confirmation bias is a consistent but individually undifferentiated phenomenon, and that accumulated media experience may buffer misinformation susceptibility more effectively than cognitive motivation alone.
Author: Cantu, Anthony
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7221372546
