Emotional controllability beliefs – the moderating effects of autistic traits on young people's anxiety and depression
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Study designs: Randomized Controlled Trial, Clinical Trial
Abstract: Adolescent mental health difficulties are prevalent and increasing, with one in five young people aged 16–19 meeting criteria for a probable mental health disorder. A growing body of evidence points to the importance of Emotion Controllability Beliefs (ECB) — beliefs about the extent to which emotions can be controlled — which are theorised to function as a mechanism influencing the use of emotion regulation strategies and, in turn, mental health outcomes. This study evaluates an ECB intervention, a brief, digital school-based programme designed to strengthen these beliefs in a large multi-school UK post-16 sample and examines whether autistic traits moderate intervention outcomes at two-week and three-month follow up. The study used a randomised waitlist-controlled design. Young people aged 16–20 were recruited from ten schools and colleges across England (n = 444; intervention n = 275, control n = 169). They completed pre-intervention, two-week post-intervention, and three-month follow-up online surveys. Measures included the Emotion Beliefs Questionnaire (EBQ), the Revised Child Anxiety and Depression Scale (RCADS), the Depression Anxiety Stress Scales (DASS-21), the Emotion Regulation Questionnaire — Child and Adolescent version (ERQ-CA), and the Autism Spectrum Quotient 10-item version (AQ-10). Primary analyses used ANCOVAs controlling for baseline scores, with PROCESS moderated regression analyses (Hayes, 2022) examining whether autistic traits moderated intervention effects. Three-month follow-up analyses were conducted with the available subsample (n = 86–98, approximately 20% of the original sample). At two weeks, the intervention produced a significant reduction in emotion controllability beliefs (F(1, 184) = 10.40, p = .001, partial η² = .054), replicating prior findings in an independent and larger sample. However, no significant changes were observed in emotion regulation strategy use (i.e., cognitive reappraisal, expressive suppression) or mental health outcomes at two weeks, consistent with the theoretical expectation that effects take longer to emerge. Autistic traits significantly moderated the effect on anxiety at two weeks (b = 1.199, p = .004, ΔR² = .020), with a potentially iatrogenic effect emerging at high autistic trait levels (b = 3.54, p = .003). No moderation was found for beliefs, strategies, or depression. At three months, the initial belief change did not persist, suggesting that without ongoing reinforcement, initial shifts are not sustained. However, a significant delayed reduction in expressive suppression emerged (F(1, 84) = 5.556, p = .021, partial η² = .062), primarily within those with lower autistic trait range (Johnson-Neyman threshold AQ-10 = 0.082; 51.8% of sample). Importantly, the iatrogenic anxiety effect had not resolved at three months, with Johnson-Neyman analysis indicating the intervention effect on anxiety remained significant for 76.7% of the follow-up sample. Among individuals with higher autistic traits, those in the intervention group reported significantly higher anxiety than the control group at three months (b = 6.653, p = .005). These findings make several original contributions. This is the first study to evaluate the intervention across multiple schools with three-month follow-up, providing the first empirical support for a delayed treatment effect on suppression and confirming that the theoretical sleeper effect hypothesis is warranted. It is also the first study to examine autistic traits as a moderating variable in ECB intervention research, identifying a potential iatrogenic effect on anxiety for young people with higher autistic traits that persisted at three months. Whilst the intervention shows promise as a scalable first-line tool in post-16 settings, these findings highlight the importance of monitoring differential outcomes and not assuming uniform effects for all learners. Implication for educational psychology practice, intervention design and future research are discussed.
Author: Robertson, Anna
Institution: University College London
Language: English
Subfield: Clinical Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: autistic traits, adolescent anxiety, adolescent depression, emotion regulation, cognitive reappraisal, expressive suppression, school-based intervention, digital mental health interventions, moderation, iatrogenic disease, autism spectrum disorder, Autism Spectrum Quotient, emotion regulation strategies, adolescent mental health
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7221412408
