The COVID Cohort Meets the New Normal: Community College Student Experiences With Instructional Modality Selection
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: As community colleges continue to expand online and in-person course offerings, discussions of instructional modality are often framed in terms of student preference. Yet such framing may oversimplify how students understand and evaluate their options. This study explores how traditional-age community college students, whose secondary education was disrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic, make decisions about course modality in a post-pandemic context. Understanding how students navigate these choices is increasingly important as institutions seek to balance flexibility, access, and equity while determining the mix of courses offered across modalities.The study was guided by two research questions: (1) How do traditional-age community college students understand and evaluate their options between in-person and asynchronous online learning, and in what ways have their experiences shaped these evaluations? and (2) How do institutional and contextual factors influence students’ modality-related decisions? The study draws on Iloh’s (2019) multidimensional college-going framework and Bronfenbrenner’s bioecological theory to examine how individual experiences, institutional structures, and broader environmental influences interact in students’ decision-making processes.Using a qualitative case study approach, I conducted semi-structured interviews with ten first-year students at a Northern California community college. Participants were between the ages of 18 and 22 and represented a range of educational backgrounds and modality experiences. Interviews explored students’ understanding of instructional modalities, factors influencing course selection, and reflections on both Fall and Spring enrollment decisions. Data were analyzed through iterative cycles of deductive and inductive coding informed by the study’s theoretical framework.Findings challenge the notion that students hold stable or universal modality preferences. Rather than identifying as either “online learners” or “in-person learners,” most participants described making course-by-course decisions based on the subject matter, perceived learning demands of a course, and their own academic strengths and needs. Students frequently weighed considerations such as opportunities for interaction, access to immediate feedback, scheduling flexibility, and their ability to remain motivated and organized in asynchronous environments. Participants’ experiences during pandemic-era schooling remained a significant point of reference when evaluating modality options. For some students, negative experiences with remote learning contributed to continued avoidance of asynchronous online courses, while others described revising their initial assumptions after gaining experience in college-level online courses. Across interviews, students demonstrated an awareness that success in asynchronous environments requires substantial self-regulation, time management, and personal accountability. Institutional and contextual factors—including course availability, scheduling constraints, employment obligations, and transportation considerations—also shaped the options students ultimately pursued.The findings suggest that modality decisions are more complex than commonly assumed and that student “preferences” are often intertwined with prior experiences, institutional conditions, and competing life demands. For community colleges seeking to advance educational equity, these findings highlight the importance of moving beyond simplistic assumptions about modality preference and considering how course scheduling, modality availability, and student support structures influence students’ opportunities to make meaningful choices. The study contributes to ongoing conversations about equitable access and student success in an evolving post-pandemic higher education landscape.
Author: Reeve, Melissa
Institution: University of California, Davis
Language: English
Topic: Online and Blended Learning
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: community college students, instructional modality, online learning, asynchronous learning, face-to-face teaching, course selection, COVID-19 pandemic, student decision-making, modality preference, self-regulation, time management, institutional factors, bioecological model, student experience, transportation barriers, employment obligation, scheduling constraints, access and equity, first-year students, higher education enrollment decisions
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7221481761
