Work

"We're here, we're queer, we're fascist! Get used to it." Identity conflict in the homosexual radical right

Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The homosexual radical right is often seen to be oxymoronic. It seems incomprehensible for many that a marginalised group within society—homosexuals—can support a political movement which is both homophobic and oppressive to others. It has been suggested that the interests, needs, and demands of being both homosexual and politically radical right are so fundamentally opposed that there cannot be a synthesis between these two identities. I characterise this juxtaposition and incongruence of identities as identity conflict. This identity conflict is the central research area of this thesis. This thesis uses Sheldon Stryker’s (1991; 2001) symbolic interactionist approach to identity. This approach views identity as a commitment that is strengthened through performance. In understanding identity in this way, it also gives insight into conflict between identities and how an individual can successfully resolve identity conflict. This approach conceptualises identity commitments in terms of a salience hierarchy. This salience hierarchy is established by assessing an individual’s commitment to an identity and framing any conflict as a challenge to this commitment. I argue that the homosexual radical right can maintain congruent identities by resolving any challenges to their identity commitments. Through a critical discourse analysis (CDA) of forty-four texts, images, and memes that the homosexual radical right has produced, I suggest that many members of the homosexual radical right either successfully resolve, or do not experience, identity conflict. This identity conflict is resolved through two strategies: 1) by denying the conflict exists, or 2) by minimising the conflict to a tolerable level. The first strategy has three methods: Primarily, the homosexual radical right engages in a reconstruction of radical right ideology to permit homosexuals to exist within the ideological typology. The additional two methods of the first strategy are to either fictionalise the homophobia of the radical right, or by suggesting that the conflict is artificially created by the ‘Other’. The second strategy of identity conflict resolution is the minimisation of identity conflict which is achieved through creating an Other, which significantly threatens both homosexuals and White people that any identity conflict can be tolerable. This thesis contributes to a small field of work on the relationship between sexual and political identities, of which it is the first instance of a suggestion that the radical right as an ideology can be queered.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7221496191
Cites: 273
Cited by:
Related to: 10