Changing Climate Narratives: Exploring the Influence of Emotive Framing on Pro-Environmental Behaviour and Eco-Paralysis Among Young Adults
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: Climate change affects mental health on a global scale, with eco-anxiety emerging as a leading concern, disproportionately affecting young people. Eco-anxiety has two distinct behavioural outcomes, either driving pro-environmental behaviour or aversion to climate change-related information (eco-paralysis). This study investigated the influence of emotive framing—specifically alarmism vs realistic optimism—on pro-environmental behaviour and eco-paralysis, considering the roles of self-efficacy and eco-anxiety (as a moderator and covariate respectively). In a between-subjects experiment, 296 participants were randomly assigned to view a short animation framed as either optimistic, alarmist, or neutral (control). Contrary to expectations, neither the alarmist nor optimistic frames led to pro-environmental behaviour or eco-paralysis. Additionally, self-efficacy did not moderate the relationship, nor did eco-anxiety act as a covariate. However, eco-anxiety was a significant predictor of pro- environmental behaviour and negative correlations were observed between eco-paralysis and pro-environmental behaviour, as well as between self-efficacy and eco-paralysis. Although it is possible that the effects of emotive framing on eco-paralysis and pro-environmental behaviour are negligible, it may also be that the emotive frames used may not have been strong enough to elicit such effects. Future research should explore alternative framing techniques, perhaps using more potent manipulations to better understand how climate communication can effectively motivate pro-environmental behaviour and mitigate the psychological burden of eco-anxiety on young people.
Author: Winter, Lily
Institution: University of Otago
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Climate action
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7221497610
