Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The COVID-19 pandemic has posed not only severe health and governance challenges but also an unprecedented information crisis. Governments play a crucial role in maintaining information order and public trust during the pandemic. However, existing studies have often focused on macro-level response strategies, lacking sufficient attention to how response strategies interact with response modes, public reactions, and contextual factors on rumor response behaviors. Grounded in Situational Crisis Communication Theory (SCCT), this study develops a four-dimensional analytical framework containing rumor types, rumor response strategies, rumor response modes, and public reactions. This study analyzed Weibo (n=278) and Twitter (n=293) rumor response posts from governmental accounts in China and the United States during the early stage of the COVID-19 pandemic. The researcher used content and text analysis to explore response patterns and public reactions. The findings indicate that the two countries adopted the same four response strategies (denial, refutation, attack, and guidance), but differed in frequency, narrative styles, and presentation forms. The Chinese government frequently uses denial and refutation strategies, emphasizing fact-checking, joint narrative, and image-oriented content. The US government preferred the guide and denial strategies, with no prominent presence of fact-checking. The US government tended to use the releasable narrative and provide external links for users to explore more information. Besides, the Chinese government tended to respond to bogie rumors, while the US responded more to the wish and bogie rumors. Chinese comments showed a dual structure of trust differentiation between the central and local governments, accompanied by expressions of identification with collective interests and sacrifice. American comments have focused on distrust and skepticism towards the federal government and the president, alongside concerns regarding the transparency of information and the rationality of policies. Building on these findings, the study proposes a Contextualized Rumor Response Model (CRRM) for understanding governmental rumor response in cross-national public health crises.
Author: Wu, Jing
Institution: University of Ljubljana
Language: English
Subfield: Communication
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7221578673
