The Present Model Theory of Consciousness
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Conscious perception, imagery and dreaming differ in what drives them, yet may share one actively maintained organization: a single running model of the present that covers the world, the body and where one is in it. I propose that operating this organization constitutes experience. The theory names three features needed for any experience: running, in which the model’s content advances by its own dynamics when the senses go quiet; joint repair, in which the model’s parts check and correct one another; and a single present, in which every content is placed relative to one now. It separates three claims with different burdens of evidence: that this organization is necessary (H1), that operating it is experience (H2), and that the material a system is made of does not matter (H3). Small simulated networks show that parts of the organization can be measured, told apart from known look-alikes and partly learned; they do not show that any system experiences anything. In simulations, systems recovered from corruption without two-way repair, and two-way repair may arise wherever parts exchange estimates, so the presence of some repair settles little; what matters is which parts form one model, and the theory does not yet have a rule for drawing that boundary. The main test planned so far is in people: whether content that is not experienced can both run and be in two-way repair with experienced content. Because evidence of experience in people comes mostly through report, which needs access, the theory and global workspace theory may give the same result in nearly every feasible experiment; separating them needs an intervention that disrupts repair without disrupting broadcast, and whether one exists is the first question. The paper sets out the theory’s predictions, which of them could separate it from global workspace theory, the results that would refute it, and when a failed test counts against the theory rather than against one proposed implementation.
Author: Pillai, Pramod
Language: English
Subfield: Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7221690382
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: