Get started
Work

The contingency of pain: Maternal detachment, bereavement trauma, and Indigenous women's resilience in Tommy Orange's There There

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Native American literature constitutes a vital archive for examining how inherited grief and social dislocation shape Indigenous lives in the present. In There There (2018), Tommy Orange foregrounds the emotional and relational consequences of maternal absence and abandonment within contemporary Native communities. The novel depicts Indigenous women not merely as passive inheritors of historical pain but as figures through whom trauma, memory, and resilience converge. This paper examines the contingency of pain, arguing that suffering in the novel is not an inevitable condition but a historically mediated and socially reproduced experience that persists across generations. Drawing upon Cathy Caruth’s theory of trauma as belated and repetitive, the study examines how unresolved loss re-emerges in fragmented kinship structures, emotional withdrawal, and patterns of silence. Sara Ahmed’s framework of the cultural politics of emotion further enables an analysis of pain as relational and circulatory, shaping attachment, exclusion, and communal belonging. Through the close analysis of the character Jacquie Red Feather, the paper contends maternal detachment should be understood not as individual failure but as a symptom of enduring structural marginalization and inherited disruption. At the same time, Orange resists a deterministic narrative of damage. Indigenous women articulate resilient presence through caregiving, narrative recalibration, and acts of relational endurance. The study concludes that ongoing negotiation within the affective afterlife of historical trauma and violence, thereby reaffirming indigenous continuity within contemporary precarity.
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23372428
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7221793293
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10