Cost And Productivity Analysis Of Installing 40 X 60 X 120 U-Ditches Using Heavy Equipment Compared To Manual Methods In Sumur Welut, Lakarsantri District, Surabaya
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: General Background Drainage infrastructure development plays a crucial role in mitigating hydrometeorological disasters and supporting sustainable urban resilience in metropolitan areas like Surabaya. Specific Background The installation of precast concrete U-ditches is widely implemented in urban drainage projects, yet contractors frequently face strategic dilemmas when choosing between manual labor and heavy equipment methods. Knowledge Gap Although mechanical methods are generally assumed to be superior, detailed empirical evaluations comparing direct costs and work productivity per unit between manual and heavy equipment approaches under identical field conditions remain limited. Aims This study aims to analyze and compare work productivity, direct costs, and cost efficiency between the heavy equipment method utilizing an excavator and forklift and the manual method for installing 40 x 60 x 120 cm U-ditches in the Sumur Welut drainage project, Surabaya. Results Field evaluations indicate that the heavy equipment method achieves a daily productivity of 18 units, which is significantly higher than the 2.5 units achieved by the manual method, while yielding a direct cost of Rp 221,667 per unit that proves more economical and time-saving. Novelty This research provides empirical evidence that mechanization successfully compensates for higher daily investment through economies of scale and accelerated schedule completion in urban drainage construction. Implications The findings serve as a reliable quantitative reference for project managers and planners in selecting optimal construction methods to enhance time and cost efficiency in similar infrastructure projects. Key Findings Highlights The heavy equipment method achieves a daily productivity of 18 units, significantly outperforming the manual method's 2.5 units. Mechanized U-ditch installation provides superior time efficiency, reducing project duration from twelve days down to six working days. Despite higher initial daily equipment rental expenses, high-volume production makes the mechanized approach highly cost-effective per unit. Keywords Cost Analysis, Productivity, U-ditch, Heavy Equipment, Manual Method
Authors: Fila Atma Jalu Eka Irawan, Atik Wahyuni
Institution: Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo
Language: English
Field: Decision Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7221831835
