Police Accountability and Police Transparency: Implications for Thecriminal Justice System
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Police institutions occupy a powerful position in the criminal justice system. Their decisions influence whether information about an offence is recorded, evidence is preserved, a suspect is arrested, a victim receives protection and a prosecution reaches court on a reliable foundation. Because police officers exercise coercive powers on behalf of the State, their conduct must be governed by law, open to appropriate scrutiny and capable of correction when standards are breached. This paper examines the relationship between police accountability and police transparency in India and evaluates their implications for the administration of criminal justice. It adopts a doctrinal and analytical methodology based on constitutional principles, legislation, reported judicial decisions and institutional reform materials. The paper argues that transparency and accountability are related but distinct: transparency makes information available for scrutiny, whereas accountability requires explanation, review and, where justified, consequences or remedies. The study considers the effects of these principles on victims, accused persons, evidence, prosecution, courts, police professionalism and public confidence. It also addresses challenges including political interference, weak external oversight, delays, fear of retaliation, poor record-keeping and the misuse of confidentiality. The paper concludes that sustainable reform requires a layered system combining internal supervision, independent review of serious allegations, accessible complaint mechanisms, reliable digital records, reasoned decisions, protection of privacy and periodic public reporting. Properly designed accountability is not opposed to effective policing; it strengthens the legality, legitimacy and long-term effectiveness of police work.
Author: Kirandeep Kaur
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7222704168
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: