Work

Techno-Economic Assessment of Steam Recovery Integration in the Bayer Process for Low-carbon Alumina Production

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Recovering available waste water vapour from the alumina refining process presents a promising method to improve overall energy efficiency and reduce reliance on fossil fuel steam generation. This study conducted a comprehensive techno-economic assessment to understand the viability of recovering waste vapour (typically at ~1 atmospheric pressure or 0.14 bar) from the Bayer process. Various steam recovery technologies, including multi-stage MVR (mechanical vapour recompression), multi-stage TVR (thermal vapour recompression), and integrated TVR-MVR systems were assessed in terms of their energy consumption and coefficient of performance (COP) for recompressing vapour to high-pressure (typically 5-15 bar, 175°C to 230°C), representative of low-temperature digestion condition in the refining process. In particular, steam-cleaning and recovery from the steam calcination (H2 in oxygen-steam combustion or fully electrified calcination) was analysed, which eliminates the direct CO2 emissions from natural gas combustion during calcination while generates high-concentration steam that can be recovered for the Bayer process. Firstly, this study assessed the technical viability of a novel retrofitted calciner design that accommodates H2 in oxygen-steam combustion integrated with steam recovery. A detailed calcination model was developed in Aspen Plus to estimate the heat utilisation efficiency, calciner units such as cyclones’ performance and overall energy consumption under steam environment, and to compare with conventional natural gas/air combustion. Energy consumption under H2 in oxygen-steam calcination was calculated to be slightly higher than natural gas/air combustion, at 2.89-2.96 GJ/tAl2O3 (LHV) compared with 2.88 GJ/tAl2O3 (LHV). This increase is caused by the inhibited pre-calcination reaction, which indirectly lowers the heat transfer efficiency under a steam-rich environment than in an air environment. However, it produces high-concentration steam for recovery, enabling efficient recovery of its latent energy. Cyclone performance under the steam environment was found to remain comparable pressure drop and separation efficiency (>97%) using recirculated superheated steam as carrier gas. Secondly, this study estimated an integrated steam cleaning and recovery process for high-concentration steam recovery from steam calcination (H2 in oxygen-steam combustion and fully electrified calcination), with an integrated venturi scrubber removing fine particles prior to multi-stage MVR system. The work also examined the recovery of diluted steam mixed with N2 and CO2 from air calcination (including H2/air and natural gas/air combustion) by adopting gas separation process prior multi-stage MVR system. Results show that the associated energy penalty for gas separation and steam cleaning accounts for 5%-9% of the energy consumption in steam recovery, with remaining 91-95% for MVR systems. Steam recovery from fully electrified calcination or H2 in oxy‑steam combustion achieves recovery rates of 0.64 tsteam/tAl2O3 and 0.86 tsteam/tAl2O3, respectively, with an energy consumption of 0.54 GJ/tsteam. Steam recovery from air‑fired calcination achieves lower recovery rate of 0.54-0.55 tsteam/tAl2O3, consuming 0.71 GJ/tsteam energy. The recovered steam from various calcination pathways was estimated to offset 27%, 32%, and 43% of the total steam demand in the Bayer circuit, assuming an average steam consumption of 2 tsteam/tAl2O3, which is presently supplied by natural gas boilers. This leads to corresponding reductions in overall energy consumption for steam supply by 21%, 27% and up to 36%, respectively. Thirdly, the study assessed various steam recovery technologies, including multi-stage MVR, multi-stage TVR, and proposed integrated TVR-MVR by developing comprehensive models in Aspen Plus and MATLAB. Among the options, MVR system achieves the highest efficiency, achieving COP values of 3.2 (for the vapour inlet pressure at 0.14 bar) and 5.7 (For the vapour inlet pressure at 1 bar) for recompressing steam to 8 bar, representative of steam condition in the low-temperature digestion, whereas natural gas boilers operate at a COP of 0.8. The integrated TVR-MVR configuration reduces the MVR stage and thereby lowers the operational risk. However, the COP decreases to 1.9 when compressing from ~1 bar to 8 bar. Multi-stage TVR is less technically feasible, with COP reducing to 1.0 (for the case of 0.14 bar) and 1.4 (for the case of ~1 bar) for recompressing to 8 bar. Finally, the study assessed the optimisation of steam recovery from both calcination and the Bayer circuit using multi-stage MVR systems. The results demonstrate the 100 % of steam demand for Bayer circuit usage can potentially be met via internal recovery, with contributions of 43% from the proposed scenario of H2 in oxygen‑steam calcination, 9% from digestion, 37% from evaporation, and 11% from precipitation. The proposed steam recovery enables energy reduction from 6.64 to 1.41 GJ/tAl2O3, representing 79% energy conservation relative to steam generation from natural gas boilers. In addition, transitioning from fossil fuel steam generation to electricity-powered steam recovery could eliminate direct carbon emissions. Economically, in comparison with natural gas boilers at a gas price of 7.5 US$/GJ plus a carbon capture and storage cost (CCS) of 179 US$/tCO2, the estimated levelised cost of decarbonised steam for the Bayer circuit (LCOSB) decreases by 50 % at a fixed 70 US$/MWh electricity price, reducing from 110.2 to 55.1 US$/tAl2O3. This reduction is accompanied by a significant increase in capital investment for the MVR systems, accounting for 50 % of LCOSB. This study evaluates key decarbonisation technologies that could be implemented in the Bayer process, including hydrogen combustion for calcination, mechanical and thermal vapour recompression for steam recovery, and electric boilers for steam generation, with particular emphasis on the technical and economic viability of steam recovery. The results demonstrate the potential of these technologies from both technical and economic perspectives to support low-carbon alumina production.
Author: Ning, Siyun
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7222768380
Cites: 165
Cited by:
Related to: 10