Work

How does land-use change reorganise insect assemblages?

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Insects play crucial roles in both natural and managed ecosystems. Their rapid decline in some places around the world have been widely reported, but the extent of and reasons for this decline are not yet fully understood. My thesis aims to understand how land use change and intensification reorganise insect assemblages – structurally as well as in terms of overall diversity – thereby improving understanding of where declines would be expected and the ecological impacts they are likely to have. The PREDICTS database, which has collated site-level data on many thousands of terrestrial insect assemblages facing threats relating to land-use change, allows detailed modelling of how land use change and intensity affect different taxonomic and functional groups of insects. GLiTRS (Global Insect Threat-Response Synthesis), a large NERC-funded collaboration to develop and validate a threat-response model for insects, is broadening the approach in developing a database that considers functional trait data for many insect groups. However, because most of the data sources in those databases have sampled only single groups using single sampling methods, analyses have not considered linked responses among groups, restricting the development of more mechanistic models. In Chapter 2, I test how major co-occurring insect orders respond to land-use change. By analysing only studies that sampled multiple co-occurring insect orders simultaneously at the same sites, I account for the potential for spatial, geographic and sampling bias. I found that land-use effects differ significantly among co-occurring orders: interaction effects between taxonomic order and land use are consistently stronger than the main effect of land use, revealing widespread and significant divergence among co-occurring orders. Chapter 3 presents the first global synthesis of how land-use change affects total insect biomass and its two components— species’ abundance and average body mass. Across most human-modified land uses total insect biomass is markedly lower (at least 3 - 40%; I discuss reasons why the true reductions are likely to be greater) than in primary vegetation. In Chapter 4, I investigated how ecological traits mediate insect species’ vulnerability or resilience to land-use change and intensification. Across many insect assemblages around the world, land use acts as a complex trait-based filter. Species in primary vegetation have an even mix of trophic levels and egg volumes, are mostly poor dispersers, and are overwhelmingly small. By contrast, insects in high-intensity agriculture are more likely to be strong dispersers, to be at higher trophic levels at least as adults and have very small eggs, whereas the tendency for small body size is less marked. Together, my thesis demonstrates that insect responses to land-use change and intensification are heterogeneous across various taxonomic, functional and biomass-based responses. As well as providing a deeper understanding of how land use change and intensification are reorganising insect assemblages and the ecosystem processes they support, my results suggest that insect assemblages are changing to a degree that has perhaps been overshadowed by a sometimes simplistic focus on questions about net declines.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7222854539
Cites: 300
Cited by:
Related to: 9