Work

Configurational Meta-Analysis: A Set-Theoretic Approach to Cross-Study Evidence Synthesis in Information Systems

Type: article
Abstract: Configurational Meta-Analysis (CMA) extends set-theoretic reasoning from primary empirical cases to published studies as cases for cross-study evidence synthesis. We formalize an IS-oriented protocol integrating corpus construction, construct harmonization, calibration from textual evidence, truth-table analysis, robustness assessment, and reporting. We demonstrate the protocol with 35 studies of agentic AI systems, calibrated for autonomy, coordination architecture, institutional embeddedness, governance clarity, and operational viability. The analysis identifies a concentrated configuration associated with outcome presence and multiple equifinal configurations associated with outcome absence. These patterns are interpreted as provisional insights from a recent, heterogeneous evidence base rather than direct causal estimates. CMA complements systematic reviews, bibliometric analysis, statistical meta-analysis, and primary-data fsQCA by enabling explicit assessment of conjunction, equifinality, and configurational asymmetry across calibrated study-level evidence.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7222992467
Cites: 32
Cited by:
Related to: 10