James II and Wales. By WilliamGibson. Cardiff: University of Wales Press. 2026. xvii + 286 p. £24.99 (pb). ISBN 978‐1‐83772‐316‐4.
Year: 2026
Type: book-review
Abstract: William Gibson is well equipped to explore the impact of James II's short reign in Wales; alongside publications that examine the intricate intersections of British political and religious history in the long eighteenth century, his body of work has reshaped how the Welsh political and religious landscape should be considered.Situated at the earlier end of Gibson's opus, this book illuminates how developments under James II would continue to shape religious life in Wales and beyond in the following century.The introduction rightly stresses that this is a book 'about Wales' ( 14), and as such, James II's reign and the subsequent invasion of William of Orange requires consideration in light of the unique factors that distinguish Wales: the Welsh language, the gentry and their kinship ties, Wales's political significance within Britain, and attitudes towards religion, all of which played a role in creating a uniquely Welsh response to James II's reign.Across ten chapters, Gibson demonstrates how James misjudged Wales's political and religious undercurrents, and his London-centric view led to the assumption that Whig opposition in Wales had been eradicated and that the formidable Welsh loyalty to the Stuart dynasty was absolute.Ultimately, James failed to recognise that the people of Wales were actively trying to reconcile their commitment to their monarch with their Protestant faith and that the Welsh political nation was far less unified than he believed.His absolutist methods therefore alienated the very people whom he needed to secure his throne, and thus, from 1685 to 1688, Wales became not the 'bastion of loyalty' (15) James had hoped for, but rather a 'bastion of opposition' (xv).Following the historiographical introduction, Chapter 2 examines the religious and political climate in Wales before James's accession, highlighting that Wales experienced its own Popish-Plot prior to the one in England.Between 1678 and 1682, tension between Catholics and Protestants increased; the Duke of Beaufort, Lord President of the Council of Wales, sought to advance Charles II's increasingly anti-Whig agenda by removing Wales's Whig exclusionists who wanted the crown to bypass James Duke of York and go to his illegitimate but Protestant son, James, the Duke of Monmouth.The deeply Protestant gentry of South Wales became increasingly concerned that Beaufort was not only a Catholic sympathiser but that he was influencing local elections to encourage a Tory resurgence.Chapter 3 explores the reaction to James's accession, how he rewarded Welsh support, and devotes particular attention to his visit to the shrine of St Winifred at Holywell in 1687.The visit publicly displayed James's Catholic piety at a critical point in his reign; his wife, Mary of Modena, had failed to carry a male heir, and James's ambition for a Catholic dynasty was waning; later, the visit became, as Chapter 8 explores, a means to discredit the king and the subsequent birth of his son.Gibson then shifts from the chronological narrative of the opening chapters to a prosopographical methodology, which examines the response to James's reign within different groups of Welsh society according to shared characteristics.Chapter 4 explores the response of Welsh MPs; Chapter 5 examines judges and lawyers; Chapter 6 considers the gentry, the Three Questions and the Quo Warranto proceedings, an attempt by James to purge the Welsh boroughs of his opposition; and Chapter 7 examines the peerage, both temporal and spiritual.Through this approach, Gibson demonstrates that Tory loyalism in Wales did not outweigh Anglican commitment.The Tory ideology of divine right and non-resistance was not absolute but existed alongside an allegiance to the established Church.Consequently, even James's loyal Tory supporters in Wales felt the need to defend it against him.His attempt to purge the Welsh boroughs further alienated the gentry by undermining their longstanding influence; thus, his heavy-handed tactics pushed once loyal
Author: Rachael Harman
Institution: Aberystwyth University
Language: English
Subfield: History
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W7223413654
