Year: 2026
Type: report
Abstract: The G20 faces a fundamental institutional challenge. The need for international cooperation is growing, while geopolitical rivalry and divergent national interests increasingly obstruct comprehensive agreements. Consensus remains valuable, but it can also produce paralysis or commitments too weak to address the problems at hand. The G20 must therefore develop an additional capacity: to organise effective collective action when agreement among all its members is unavailable. This paper proposes that future G20 Presidencies systematically convene, support and coordinate issue-based Pivotal Power Coalitions (PPCs). These coalitions would bring together the countries whose participation is particularly important for addressing specific international problems. Their membership would vary according to the capabilities, interests and responsibilities required. Participants could include G20 members and non-members alike. The proposal builds on a three-tier operating architecture (Snower, 2026a): 1. Consensus where possible: retain G20-wide agreement as the preferred basis for collective commitments. 2. Broad consensus where feasible: permit willing countries to proceed when overwhelming support exists, without imposing obligations on dissenters. 3. Pivotal Power Coalitions where necessary: organise ambitious cooperation among functionally pivotal countries when broader agreement cannot generate sufficiently effective action. The central innovation is not the creation of small coalitions. Such arrangements already exist across trade, finance, climate, technology and security. Rather, it is to give the G20 a systematic role in helping these coalitions succeed, managing their interactions, limiting harmful spillovers and enabling successful cooperation to expand.
Author: Snower, Dennis J
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7223500087
