Work

Beyond the Forced-Voluntary Dichotomy: The Limits of Regional and National Legal Frameworks in Addressing Mixed Migration in the Horn of Africa

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation examines the structural mismatch between contemporary migration governance and the empirical realities of human mobility in the Horn of Africa. While global, continental, sub-regional, and national legal and policy frameworks continue to rely on traditional, dichotomous categorisations – specifically the voluntary-forced and internal- international binaries – the regional migratory landscape is characterised by complex, multi- causal flows of mixed migrants. Driven by the intertwined pressures of armed conflict, political violence, climate-induced environmental stress, and structural economic underdevelopment, individuals move along fluid continuums that resist rigid classification. Adopting an interpretivist qualitative research design, this study combines a systematic literature review, policy and legal framework analysis, and a comparative case-study methodology focusing on Somalia and Eritrea. The empirical findings reveal that over-reliance on static categories creates severe, systematic protection gaps, effectively trapping vulnerable populations in a state of high precarity. Ultimately, this dissertation synthesises these gaps to advance an integrated analytical framework, offering recommendations to rethink migration responses beyond the binary trap.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7223630052
Cites: 72
Cited by:
Related to: 10