From Replacement Feasibility to Financing Choice: A Capital Budgeting Perspective on Aging Industrial Assets
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Aging industrial assets pose a significant financial challenge for manufacturing firms because machines that appear inexpensive from an accounting perspective may generate increasing economic costs due to maintenance escalation, downtime risk, energy inefficiency, and declining reliability. Previous analysis of an aging palletiser machine confirmed that replacement was financially feasible, with a positive NPV, an IRR exceeding the WACC, and an acceptable discounted payback period. However, the optimal financing strategy for implementing the replacement remained unclear. This study extends conventional capital budgeting by examining financing choice after replacement feasibility has been established. Using a quantitative single-case design and a 10-year discounted cash-flow model, the study compares three financing scenarios: 100% equity, 50% equity–50% debt, and 100% debt. Project feasibility is evaluated using NPV, IRR, and Discounted Payback Period, while financing feasibility is assessed through Equity NPV, Equity IRR, Cash Flow to Equity, Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR), liquidity risk, and financial flexibility. The findings confirm that the replacement project is financially feasible under all project-level indicators. Nevertheless, financing structures produce markedly different outcomes. Full equity financing is financially safe but capital intensive, whereas full debt financing increases liquidity pressure and weakens debt-service capacity. The hybrid 50% equity–50% debt scenario provides the most balanced solution by enhancing shareholder returns while maintaining repayment capacity, liquidity, and financial flexibility.
Institution: Satya Wacana Christian University
Language: English
Subfield: Finance
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7223715348
